Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Agency
You inherit a client with a history of paid links and PBNs. How do you set expectations, scope and pricing?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Set expectations around uncertainty, scope the work in phases starting with a paid diagnosis, and price for the extra risk. The honest message to the client is that nobody can tell in advance how much of their current visibility rests on the links they bought. Google’s link spam systems are designed to neutralise many manipulative links rather than punish the site, so some of those links may already count for nothing; others may still be propping up rankings that will fall when the scheme stops or is detected. A client with a paid link history needs to hear that recovery is possible but not quick, that stopping the scheme may cost them something in the short term, and that you will not continue it.
First, establish the facts
Before promising anything, find out what you are dealing with. This is the first phase, priced as a fixed-fee audit.
- Manual actions. Check the Manual actions report in Search Console. A manual action for unnatural links changes the plan completely: it needs cleanup and a reconsideration request.
- What is still active. Identify paid links and private blog network links that are still live, and whether the client is still paying anyone. Ask directly for a list of vendors and payments. Clients are often more candid in writing than in meetings.
- Who owns what. If the client or a previous agency owns the network sites, that is a different problem from purchased links on other people’s sites.
- How dependent rankings are. Look at which pages and queries the manipulative links point to, and how those pages perform compared with pages that have only natural links. Heavy dependence means higher short-term risk when the scheme stops.
- History. Match traffic drops to update dates, especially spam updates. A site that already lost visibility in a spam update may have little left to lose from cleanup.
Setting expectations
I would put three scenarios in writing after the audit:
Scenario What it looks like What the client should expect Already neutralised Links are ignored by Google; rankings rest on other signals Little change when the scheme stops; growth depends on new, legitimate work Still counting Some rankings depend on the links Possible decline when links are removed or devalued; recovery depends on replacing them with earned authority over months Manual action Search Console shows an unnatural links action Cleanup, disavow and a reconsideration request; recovery after the action is lifted is often partial, since the links no longer help Avoid promising a timeline for recovery. What you can promise is a timeline for the work: the audit, the cleanup and the start of legitimate link and content work.
On disavowing
Google’s position is that most sites do not need to use the disavow tool, and that it is mainly intended for sites with a manual action or with a significant number of spammy, artificial links they are worried about. A client with a history of buying links and running a network is exactly the second case. If there is a manual action, a disavow file is part of the reconsideration request. If there is not, disavowing the clearly paid and network links is a reasonable precaution, but set expectations that it may produce no visible change, and that removing links which were still helping can reduce rankings.
Scope in phases
- Audit (fixed fee): the investigation above, a written risk summary and a recommendation.
- Remediation (fixed fee or time-based): stopping active schemes, removal requests for paid links where possible, a disavow file, a reconsideration request if needed, and dismantling or disconnecting owned network sites.
- Rebuilding (retainer): content, technical work and legitimate link earning, with a minimum term long enough to show results.
Contract terms that protect both sides
- The client confirms that paid link and network activity will stop, and that they will tell you about any vendor still active.
- You are not responsible for outcomes caused by links placed before your engagement.
- Success measures for the first months focus on completed work and risk reduction, not rankings.
- A minimum term for the rebuilding phase, since legitimate authority takes time.
- A right to end the engagement if manipulative link buying resumes.
Pricing for the risk
These engagements take more senior time, carry more reputational risk and involve harder client conversations than a clean site. Price the audit separately so you are paid for the diagnosis even if the client decides not to continue. Set the retainer at a level that reflects the extra reporting and communication, and do not discount it to win the account. Clients who bought cheap links often look for cheap agencies; the ones worth working with understand that fixing the problem costs more than creating it did.
Hypothetical example:
An online retailer comes to an agency after its previous provider spent two years buying guest posts and running a small network. The audit finds no manual action, about 300 paid links still live, and five network sites owned by the previous agency pointing to key category pages. Those categories have been sliding since the last spam update. The agency explains that the links are probably already discounted, recommends disconnecting the network sites and disavowing the paid domains, and sets expectations that the categories may not recover until the site earns real authority. The client signs a twelve-month rebuilding retainer with success measured first by work delivered and then by non-brand growth in categories without manipulative links.
Diagnose before promising, be explicit about the three scenarios, refuse to continue any scheme, scope and price in phases, and write the history and the client’s commitments into the contract. The clients who accept those terms are usually the ones who recover.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.