Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Agency
The client’s in-house team takes credit for wins and blames the agency for losses. How do you handle attribution politics?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
Niraj Raut
Stop competing for credit and make results shared by design. Attribution politics usually grows from ambiguous goals, undocumented recommendations and reports that divide outcomes into “ours” and “theirs”. The approaches that work are joint goals agreed at the start, a shared record of recommendations, decisions and implementation status, change annotations that show what happened when, results reported as joint outcomes, and blameless reviews when things go wrong. It also helps to make the in-house team look good to their own leadership, because their credibility is what keeps the agency relationship alive. When losses happen, the record shows what was recommended, what was implemented and what else changed, which removes most of the room for blame.
Why attribution politics happens
- In-house teams are judged by their leadership and want visible wins.
- Agencies are an easy explanation for problems, especially when their work is not well understood.
- Results depend on implementation, which the agency often does not control.
- Reports separate agency and in-house activity, encouraging comparison.
Practices that defuse it
Practice Effect Joint goals and KPIs agreed at the start Success is shared, not divided A shared log of recommendations, decisions and implementation status Clear record of who decided what and when Change annotations in reporting tools Outcomes connected to specific changes Reports describing results as joint No “our win, your loss” framing Blameless post-incident reviews Focus on process fixes, not fault Materials the in-house team can present to their leadership Their success becomes the agency’s success Handling losses
- Investigate the cause with evidence: releases, updates, competitor changes, seasonality.
- Present findings neutrally, referring to the shared log for what was recommended and implemented.
- Focus on what to do next rather than who is to blame.
- If recommendations were not implemented, say so factually, without accusation, and ask what would help them happen.
When credit is being taken unfairly
If the in-house team presents agency work as its own, the agency’s relationship with the executive sponsor matters. Regular, brief updates to the sponsor on joint progress, framed as partnership, make the agency’s contribution visible without undermining the in-house team. Avoid public disputes over credit; they damage the relationship more than the lost credit is worth.
Hypothetical example:
An agency’s client contact presents a strong traffic quarter to their leadership as an in-house achievement, then blames the agency the following quarter when a core update causes a dip. The agency introduces a shared recommendations log with implementation status, annotates every release and update in the reporting dashboard, and restructures quarterly reports around joint goals, highlighting the in-house team’s implementation work. In the next review with the executive sponsor, the log shows which recommendations drove the earlier gains and that the dip affected competitors equally. The tone of the relationship changes, and the client contact starts presenting results as a joint effort.
Watch for this:
Reports that emphasise what the agency recommended and the client failed to implement, however true, tend to make in-house teams defensive. Present implementation gaps as shared obstacles to solve, and offer help, such as specifications or developer support, to close them.
Make the in-house team’s work visible too
In-house teams often do the difficult part: getting developer time, persuading stakeholders, shepherding changes through release processes. Reports that credit that work openly, for example “the product team shipped the new category templates, which enabled the gains we now see”, build goodwill and reduce the in-house team’s need to claim the agency’s work. Offering them ready-made slides and summaries for their own leadership presentations also helps; when they present results well, the agency benefits from the relationship’s success rather than competing with it.
Know when the relationship cannot work
Occasionally, the politics reflect deeper problems: an in-house lead who wants the agency gone, or a leadership team that needs a scapegoat. Documented, joint reporting protects the agency in those situations, but it may not save the account. It is worth recognising early when the effort to manage politics exceeds the value of the work, and planning a professional exit with a clean handover.
Put it in the contract
Define responsibilities for recommendations, implementation and measurement in the contract, agree how results will be reported, and set a regular review with the executive sponsor. Clear roles from the start leave less room for politics later.
Agree joint goals, keep a shared log of recommendations and implementation, annotate changes, report results as joint, run blameless reviews, help the in-house team succeed with their leadership, and maintain a direct but collaborative relationship with the executive sponsor.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.