Discussion
  • Agency

Taking on direct competitors in the same city or niche as clients: where do you draw the line, and how do you handle the conflict?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • Niraj Raut
    Niraj Raut
    Original poster

    Draw the line where the clients would be competing for the same limited positions in front of the same customers. Two dentists in the same suburb competing for three places in the local pack are in direct conflict, and serving both means that success for one is often a loss for the other. Two dentists in different cities, or two companies in the same niche serving different segments, are not in real conflict and can benefit from an agency’s specialist knowledge. Where overlap exists, the minimum is disclosure and consent from both clients; beyond that, information barriers, separate teams, and exclusivity agreements when a client wants protection and is willing to pay for it. When the conflict is head-to-head, declining the second client is usually the right answer.

    Degrees of conflict

    Situation Conflict level Typical approach
    Same niche, different cities or countries Low Acceptable; mention specialisation openly
    Same niche and area, different segments or services Moderate Disclose, get consent, separate teams
    Same service, same area, competing for the same local results High Usually decline, or only with explicit consent from both and strong safeguards
    National brands competing for the same national queries High Disclose and get consent at minimum; many agencies decline

    Why local conflicts are sharper

    In local search, the map pack shows a handful of businesses. If two clients in the same area both target it, the agency is effectively deciding between them with every recommendation. Clients also share sensitive information with their agency, such as pricing, margins, leads and plans, and they need confidence it will not help a competitor. Even with the best intentions, those situations create doubts that damage the relationship when results diverge.

    Safeguards when overlap is acceptable

    • Disclosure: tell both clients before taking on the second, and get written consent.
    • Separate teams: different people work on each account, with no sharing of client-specific information.
    • Access controls: client data and documents restricted to their team.
    • Clear policy: what can be shared, such as general expertise, and what cannot, such as strategy, data and plans.
    • An exit plan: how the agency will handle the relationship if the conflict becomes unworkable.

    Exclusivity as a product

    Some clients want a guarantee that the agency will not work for competitors in their area or niche. That has real value, because it limits the agency’s market, and it can be offered at a price, with a clear definition of what counts as a competitor, the geography and the duration. Defining it precisely prevents disputes: “competing businesses offering the same service within 20 kilometres” is enforceable; “competitors” is not.

    Hypothetical example:

    An agency specialising in physiotherapy clinics serves clients in several cities. A new clinic approaches it from a suburb where an existing client operates, offering the same services. The agency explains the conflict to the prospect and declines, referring it to another agency. Later, the existing client asks for exclusivity in its region; the agency agrees to exclusivity within a defined radius for a fee added to the retainer. A clinic in a different city, offering a different specialism, becomes a client without any conflict. The agency’s reputation among clinics grows because its policy is clear and consistently applied.

    Watch for this:

    Taking on a competitor without telling an existing client is the fastest way to lose both. Clients usually find out, often through the local results themselves, and trust rarely recovers.

    Specialisation is a strength, handled openly

    Niche agencies build expertise by serving many businesses in the same industry, and clients often choose them for that reason. The expertise itself, knowing what works in the sector, is legitimately shared; what is not shared is any one client’s data, strategy or results. Being explicit about that distinction in proposals reassures clients: “we work with clinics in other regions, which is why we know this sector; we never share one client’s data or plans with another.” Most clients accept that readily, as long as their direct local competitors are not also on the roster.

    Write the policy down

    A published conflict policy, shared with prospects, removes ambiguity: which kinds of overlap the agency accepts, what it requires in consent and safeguards, and when it declines. It also makes decisions easier for the agency’s own team, who otherwise face the temptation of a new contract against an unclear principle.

    Decline head-to-head conflicts for the same limited positions, accept overlap across geographies or segments with disclosure, consent and separate teams, offer clearly defined exclusivity at a price, and publish a conflict policy so every client knows the rules before they sign.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.