Discussion
  • Agency

With num=100 gone and SERPs so personalised, do you still report ranking positions to clients at all?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    I still report positions, but differently, and never as the headline. Positions remain useful for a focused set of priority queries, tracked consistently from defined locations, as a diagnostic that explains movements in clicks and revenue. What changed after Google stopped supporting the &num=100 results parameter in September 2025 is that deep rank tracking became harder and more expensive, and Search Console’s impressions and average position shifted for many sites without any real change in rankings. Combined with personalisation and localisation, that makes sitewide average position and “keywords in the top 100” poor client metrics. Report outcomes first, then a small set of rankings that explain them.

    What changed and why it matters

    • Rank trackers were disrupted. Collecting results beyond the first page became more costly, and many tools changed their methods, limits or pricing.
    • Search Console reporting shifted. Many sites saw desktop impressions fall and average position improve from September 2025, because fewer automated deep result fetches were being counted. Year-on-year comparisons across that date mislead without annotation.
    • Results vary by user. Location, device, language and search history change what people see, and AI features and shopping units change where a given position sits on the page.

    A reporting structure that works now

    Layer What to report Source
    Outcomes Non-brand clicks, conversions, revenue or pipeline Search Console, analytics, CRM
    Visibility Impressions and clicks by page group and query group Search Console
    Priority rankings Positions for a few dozen to a few hundred commercially important queries, from fixed locations and devices Rank tracker
    SERP context Presence of AI Overviews, shopping units, local packs and other features for those queries Rank tracker with SERP feature data

    How to present rankings honestly

    1. Show distributions, not averages. “Of our 150 priority queries, 42 are in the top three, 61 in positions four to ten” is more useful than a single average.
    2. Pair positions with context. A position two below an AI Overview and a shopping unit may produce fewer clicks than position four did two years ago.
    3. Track by location where it matters. For local businesses, rankings from several points in the service area, or grid-based tools, reflect what customers see better than a single city-level check.
    4. Annotate reporting changes, especially September 2025, on any chart that crosses them.
    5. Explain the limits once, clearly, in the report’s method notes.

    Handling clients who want rankings

    Many clients measure SEO in rankings because that is what they were taught to expect. Removing rankings entirely can feel evasive. It works better to keep a priority ranking table and show, alongside it, the clicks and conversions those queries produce. Over a few reporting cycles, clients start reading the outcome columns first, especially when a ranking improvement does not produce more clicks because of a new SERP feature, or when clicks rise without a ranking change because the results layout improved.

    Hypothetical example:

    An agency’s monthly report used to lead with average position across 2,000 tracked keywords. After September 2025, the average improved sharply while client traffic did not, and the client asked what had happened. The agency rebuilt the report: non-brand clicks and leads first, then impressions by service line from Search Console, then a table of 120 priority queries with positions, SERP features and clicks. The average position chart was retired with a short explanation. The client now asks about leads and priority queries rather than a number that moved for reasons unrelated to their site.

    Watch for this:

    Year-on-year comparisons of Search Console impressions or average position that span September 2025 can show dramatic “changes” caused by reporting, not performance. Compare clicks across that date, or restate the baseline and say so.

    Choosing the priority query set

    The value of the ranking table depends on which queries are in it. Build it from the queries that drive business outcomes, not from whatever a keyword tool suggested when the account started. Good sources are the queries that already produce conversions in Search Console, the terms sales teams hear from prospects, the categories and services the client most wants to grow, and a handful of competitive benchmark terms. Group them by product line or service so the table reads as a view of the business rather than a list. Review the set twice a year: retire queries that no longer matter, add new ones, and keep a note of changes so trends stay interpretable. A set of 100 to 300 carefully chosen queries is usually more informative than thousands tracked because the tool allowed it.

    Where tracked rankings still earn their cost

    Tracked rankings are most valuable for diagnosing sudden changes, for competitive monitoring on a defined query set, for checking launches and migrations, and for local businesses where position in the map pack drives calls. They are least valuable as a broad measure of performance across thousands of queries. Cutting the tracked set to what the business actually cares about usually improves the report and reduces tool costs at the same time.

    Keep rankings as a diagnostic layer for a defined set of queries, lead with outcomes and Search Console data, show distributions and SERP context, annotate the September 2025 change, and let average position retire.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.