Discussion
  • Agency

Equity or revenue share instead of fees from startups: has it ever worked out for you? Any cautionary tales?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    Equity or revenue share in place of fees can work, but in most cases practitioners describe, it works only as a small part of the arrangement, not as a replacement for fees. Most startups fail or take many years to produce liquid value, so equity is closer to a lottery ticket than income. Revenue share looks fairer but creates constant disputes about what revenue SEO produced, and the agency depends on the client’s willingness and ability to implement recommendations. The arrangements that hold up usually combine a reduced cash fee that covers the agency’s costs with a modest equity or performance component, clear legal documentation, and a founder who genuinely values the work.

    The risks

    Risk Why it matters
    Most startups fail Equity may be worth nothing, after years of work
    Illiquidity Even successful equity may not be sellable for many years
    Attribution disputes Revenue share requires agreeing what revenue SEO caused, which is rarely clear
    Control The client decides what gets implemented, but the agency carries the risk
    Cash flow Staff and costs must be paid now; returns, if any, come later
    Legal and tax complexity Vesting, dilution, valuation and tax treatment need professional advice
    Relationship strain Disagreements become disputes about money and ownership

    When it can work

    • As a minority component. A reduced fee that covers costs, plus a small equity grant or bonus tied to specific outcomes.
    • With clear attribution. Revenue share tied to something measurable and controllable, such as revenue from specific landing pages or a referral code, rather than total revenue.
    • With a founder who implements. The agency’s success depends on execution; a founder who does not act on recommendations turns shared upside into shared nothing.
    • With proper documents. Vesting schedules, what happens if the engagement ends, information rights and treatment in future funding rounds.
    • As a deliberate portfolio bet. The agency limits equity deals to a small share of its capacity and treats any return as a bonus.

    Questions to ask before agreeing

    1. If the equity is worth nothing, can the agency afford the work at the cash fee alone?
    2. How will the equity vest, and what happens if the client ends the engagement early?
    3. For revenue share, exactly which revenue counts, how is it reported, and can the agency audit it?
    4. Does the founder have the budget and people to implement recommendations?
    5. Has a lawyer and an accountant reviewed the terms?

    Hypothetical example:

    A small agency takes equity instead of fees from three startups over two years, investing hundreds of hours. Two startups close; the third raises funding, but the agency’s shares are diluted and there is no prospect of selling them for years. Cash flow problems force the agency to cut staff. It changes its policy: equity only as a small addition to a fee that covers costs, capped at a fixed share of its capacity. Its next equity arrangement, with a founder who implements quickly, is modest but sustainable, and the relationship survives a difficult quarter because the agency is still being paid.

    Watch for this:

    Revenue share deals often collapse over reporting. If the client controls analytics and the definition of revenue, the agency has no way to verify its share. Agree data access and reporting rules in writing before starting, not after the first disagreement.

    Protect the relationship as well as the money

    Shared-upside arrangements change the relationship. The agency becomes, in a small way, an owner, and disagreements about priorities can feel like disputes between partners rather than between client and supplier. Agree how decisions about SEO work are made, what happens if the founder wants to take the business in a direction the agency thinks is unwise, and how either side can end the arrangement cleanly. Founders sometimes resent later that a supplier holds equity from an early deal; agencies sometimes feel trapped serving a client whose equity is worthless. Clear terms at the start, including an exit route, keep both sides from feeling stuck.

    Alternatives that share upside with less risk

    Performance bonuses on top of a fair fee, tied to clearly measurable outcomes, give agencies upside without betting the business. Deferred fees payable on a funding round are another option, with defined triggers. Discounted fees for a set period, in exchange for a case study and referral, can suit early-stage clients who genuinely cannot pay full rates. Each shares risk without making the agency’s survival depend on one startup’s success.

    Keep cash fees that cover your costs, treat equity or revenue share as a small bonus rather than income, insist on clear attribution, data access and legal documentation, and cap the share of your capacity you put into such deals.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.