Discussion starter: an agency question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Agency
AI has cut the hours needed for audits and content. Did you lower prices, keep them, or change the pricing model entirely?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
If AI has cut the hours needed for a deliverable, the model that holds up best is pricing by deliverable or outcome rather than by time, and then deciding per service whether to hold, lower or restructure the price. Commoditised outputs, such as basic audits and first-draft content, are already being repriced by the market, so holding their old prices is hard. Judgement-heavy work, such as strategy, prioritisation, migrations and implementation support, is worth what it was before, because its value never came from the hours spent typing. The worst option is quietly keeping hourly prices while the hours shrink; clients eventually notice, and trust is harder to rebuild than margin.
The options
Option When it fits Risk Lower prices Commoditised deliverables where competitors have already cut prices Race to the bottom; hard to raise prices later Keep prices, add depth Clients value more analysis, more pages covered, more implementation help Only works if the extra depth is visible and useful Keep prices, keep scope, bank the margin Short term Erodes trust if clients learn the effort fell sharply Move to deliverable or outcome pricing Most services Needs clear scopes and measurable outcomes Which services are being repriced
Clients have access to the same tools. They can run a crawler, ask an assistant to summarise the findings and generate a content draft. Services whose output looks like that, a list of issues from a tool, a generic content brief, a templated report, are being repriced whether an agency likes it or not. Services whose value lies in knowing which issues matter, what to do first, how to get it built, what to do when things go wrong, and who is accountable for the outcome are not being commoditised in the same way.
How to restructure pricing
- Separate commodity outputs from judgement. An audit can be split into an automated baseline, priced low or included, and the prioritisation, business case and implementation plan, priced on value.
- Price deliverables, not hours. A migration plan, a content programme of a defined size, a technical roadmap, a quarter of implementation support.
- Tie some pricing to outcomes where they are measurable and within your influence, such as completed fixes, pages published to standard or incidents prevented, rather than rankings you do not control.
- Reinvest part of the time saved in things clients value: more thorough analysis, faster turnaround, more support for implementation.
- Be ready to explain the price in terms of what the client gets, not how long it took.
What clients are really asking
When a client asks whether prices should fall because of AI, they are asking whether they are paying for effort that no longer exists. The honest response is to show what they are paying for: expertise, judgement, accountability and results. If a service really is mostly effort that AI now does, lower its price or fold it into a larger service. If it is mostly judgement, hold the price and make the judgement visible in the deliverable.
Hypothetical example:
An agency used to sell technical audits at a fixed number of days. AI-assisted crawling and analysis cut the time to produce the findings by more than half. It restructures: a low-priced automated health check, a fixed-fee prioritised audit that includes a business case and a meeting with the development team, and a monthly implementation support package. The health check brings in more small clients, the prioritised audit keeps its old price because clients value the prioritisation and business case, and the implementation package becomes the largest source of revenue. Total margin rises, and no client feels misled.
Write the new model into proposals and contracts
Deliverable pricing only works if the deliverable is defined precisely. For each service, state what is produced, what decisions it supports, what the client must provide, how many review rounds are included and what is out of scope. For outcome-linked elements, define the outcome, how it is measured, the baseline and what happens if factors outside your control intervene, such as a delayed release or a platform change. Be explicit about how AI is used in delivery and how client data is handled, which answers the question clients often do not ask directly. Clear scopes also protect the agency: when effort falls, margin improves; when a job turns out harder than expected, the change process covers it.
The competitive reality
Some competitors will cut prices sharply and deliver mostly automated work. Competing with them on price for commoditised outputs is usually a losing game. Competing on outcomes, accountability and the quality of judgement is where agencies with real expertise can hold their ground. That requires being clear, in proposals and reports, about what the agency adds beyond what tools produce.
Watch for this:
Faster production can tempt agencies to take on more clients without adding senior capacity. The judgement layer, which justifies the price, does not scale the way drafting does. If senior people spread too thin, quality falls exactly where clients are paying for it.
Move to deliverable and outcome pricing, reprice commodity outputs honestly, hold prices for judgement-heavy work, reinvest some of the saved time in visible value, and never let clients discover that effort fell while prices stayed the same.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.