Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Local SEO
Where Local Services Ads run, have LSA budgets changed map pack clicks or rankings for the same trade in your accounts?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Local Services Ads should not change map pack rankings, and Google keeps its advertising and organic ranking systems separate. What they can change is clicks and calls. When Local Services Ads appear at the top of the results, some of the searchers who would have called from the map pack call from the ad instead, so a business running both can see Business Profile calls fall while total leads rise or stay flat. Businesses that pause Local Services Ads sometimes see profile calls rise. Whether the ads are worth it depends on how many leads are genuinely additional, which you can only find out by measuring both channels together.
Ranking versus click effects
Question What to expect Do Local Services Ads improve map pack rankings? No evidence that they do; Google does not describe any such link Do they take clicks from the map pack? Plausibly yes, because they sit above it and answer the same need Do they add leads overall? Often some, especially in markets where the business does not rank in the map pack Do they increase brand searches? Possibly, through exposure; hard to measure for small businesses How to measure the real effect
- Record both channels together: Local Services Ads leads, Business Profile calls, website form leads and direction requests, week by week.
- Deduplicate. The same customer may call through the ad and later through the profile. A call tracking system or a simple “how did you find us?” question at the first call helps.
- Run an on-off test. Pause the ads for a few weeks in a quieter period, or in part of the service area if the platform allows geographic targeting, and compare total leads with the period before.
- Calculate cost per incremental lead: the ad spend divided by the leads that would not have come through organic channels.
Hypothetical example:
A plumbing business ranks in the map pack for its suburb and nearby areas, and spends a monthly budget on Local Services Ads. Its Business Profile calls have fallen since it started the ads, and the owner worries his rankings dropped. Grid checks show rankings unchanged. He pauses the ads for three weeks: profile calls rise, and total leads fall only slightly. The ads were mostly capturing people who would have called from the map pack anyway. He restarts them only for suburbs further away, where he does not appear in the map pack, and total leads rise at a lower cost.
Where Local Services Ads add most
- Areas where the business does not rank in the map pack, often further from its location.
- New businesses without enough reviews or history to rank organically yet.
- Services where the Google badge and screening reassure customers, such as trades that work inside homes.
- Busy periods where extra leads have high value and capacity exists.
They add least where the business already dominates the map pack for its core area, because the ads largely capture the same customers.
Reviews connect the two
Reviews matter in both places: Google’s documentation says review count and score factor into local search ranking, and reviews influence how an ad listing looks to customers. Asking every customer for a review therefore supports organic visibility and ad performance at the same time. Check Google’s current rules for how reviews appear in Local Services Ads in your market, since the platform has changed over time.
Watch for this:
Comparing Business Profile call volume before and after starting ads, without counting ad leads, makes it look as if the ads hurt the business. Always compare total leads and total cost across both channels.
Keep the organic listing strong either way
A common pattern is for businesses to relax their Business Profile work once ads are bringing in leads: fewer review requests, outdated photos, hours not updated for holidays. That makes the business more dependent on paid leads over time, because the organic listing slowly weakens relative to competitors who keep working on theirs. The organic listing is also the fallback if ad costs rise or the budget has to be cut. Keep the profile routine going, including reviews, photos, accurate hours and services, and treat ads as an addition on top of a healthy listing rather than a replacement for it.
Budget decisions
Treat Local Services Ads as a way to reach customers the organic listing does not, and set budgets and service areas accordingly. If testing shows most ad leads are substitutes for organic calls, reduce spend in the core area and redirect it to areas or services where the business is not visible organically. If ad leads are largely additional, the budget is doing its job. Revisit the test every few months, because rankings, competition and seasonality change.
Do not expect Local Services Ads to move map pack rankings. Expect them to shift some clicks away from the map pack, measure total leads across both channels, and aim the budget at the areas and services where organic visibility is weakest.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.