Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Local SEO
How much do you trust geogrid rank heat maps, given device, personalisation and search-point differences?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
Niraj Raut
Trust geogrid heat maps for relative comparisons over time and against competitors, not as a literal picture of what every customer sees. Grid tools simulate searches from set coordinates, usually through Google’s interfaces, and report the business’s position at each point. Real customers search from precise locations, on different devices, with personalisation, at different times, using many variations of the query, and sometimes in Maps rather than Search. A single scan is a snapshot of one simulation. Run with consistent settings, repeated, and read alongside Business Profile data such as calls and direction requests, grids are one of the most useful tools in local SEO. Read as exact rankings, they mislead.
What causes differences from real results
Factor Effect Precise user location Real users are rarely exactly on a grid point; results can change over short distances Device and interface Maps, mobile search and desktop search can show different results Personalisation Search history and previous interactions can affect results Time of day Opening hours and “open now” behaviour can change which businesses appear Query variations Customers use many phrasings; a grid usually tracks a few Normal volatility Local results fluctuate from day to day Using grids well
- Keep settings consistent: the same grid size, spacing, centre, keywords and schedule, so scans are comparable.
- Repeat scans and look at trends across several, not at one scan.
- Track several query variations for each service.
- Compare with competitors on the same grid, which is often more informative than absolute positions.
- Pair with outcomes: Business Profile calls, direction requests, website clicks and bookings.
- Check a few points manually from a real device at those locations, to sense-check the tool.
What grids are good for
- Seeing the radius within which a business appears, and how it changes over time.
- Spotting areas where competitors dominate.
- Detecting sudden drops that might indicate a profile problem, filtering or spam competitors.
- Measuring the effect of changes such as categories, reviews or website improvements, over repeated scans.
Hypothetical example:
A plumbing business’s grid scan shows it ranking in the top three across only a small area around its office, and a client panics after one scan shows poor results on the north side. Repeated weekly scans over two months show that visibility on the north side fluctuates, but the overall radius is growing slowly as reviews increase. Business Profile calls rise steadily over the same period. The agency shifts its reporting to four-week averages of grid visibility alongside calls, and the client stops reacting to individual scans.
Watch for this:
Reporting a single grid scan to a client as “your rankings” invites overreaction to normal volatility. Present averages and trends, and explain once what the grid does and does not show.
Grids for multi-location businesses
For businesses with many locations, grids are most useful when run consistently across all locations with the same settings, so they can be compared. Locations with unusually small visibility radii relative to their peers are candidates for investigation: profile problems, category mismatches, weak reviews or local competitors. Combining grid visibility with each location’s Business Profile actions helps prioritise which locations need attention, rather than trying to improve every map at once.
Explaining grids to clients
Clients see a heat map and read it literally. A short explanation, covering that each point is a simulated search from that spot, that real results vary with device and personalisation, and that trends matter more than any single scan, prevents most misunderstandings. Showing the grid next to calls and bookings keeps attention on the outcomes the grid is meant to explain.
Choosing grid settings
Grid spacing and size should reflect the business’s real service area and how far customers realistically travel. A dense urban grid with points every few hundred metres suits a café; a wider grid suits a trade business serving a whole city. Grids far larger than the service area produce alarming maps of places the business was never going to rank, which distracts from the areas that matter.
Use geogrids for trends, radius and competitor comparisons with consistent settings, repeat scans and average them, size grids to the real service area, pair them with Business Profile outcomes, and do not read a single scan as what every customer sees.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.