Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Local SEO
Review gating is banned, but asking happy customers first happens informally. Where do you draw the policy and ethical line with clients?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
The line is simple to state: every customer gets the same review request, at the same point in the process, regardless of how satisfied they seem. Google’s policies for Business Profile reviews prohibit selectively soliciting positive reviews and discouraging negative ones, and consumer protection authorities take a similar view; the US Federal Trade Commission’s 2024 rule on reviews and testimonials, for example, targets review suppression and misrepresenting reviews as representative. Asking happy customers first, informally, is selective solicitation even when nobody calls it gating. What is legitimate is choosing the right moment to ask everyone, making it easy, and responding to unhappy customers by fixing their problem, without steering them away from reviewing.
Where practices fall
Practice Assessment Automated review request sent to every customer after the job Legitimate Staff asking every customer in person at checkout or job completion Legitimate, if it really is every customer Satisfaction survey first, with review link sent only to high scorers Gating; prohibited Staff asking only customers who seem pleased Selective solicitation in practice Offering discounts or gifts for reviews Incentivised reviews; prohibited on Google and many platforms Asking unhappy customers to contact you first, while still sending them the review request Legitimate, if the review request is not withheld Why informal selection is still a problem
Informal practices are harder to detect, but they produce the same result as formal gating: a review profile that overstates satisfaction, which misleads future customers. They also expose the business if a disgruntled employee or customer reports them, and platforms may remove reviews or restrict profiles when patterns look manipulated. From a practical point of view, a profile full of perfect reviews can also look less credible to readers than one with a realistic mix and good responses.
A policy to agree with clients
- Every customer receives the review request, triggered by a completed transaction, not by a satisfaction score.
- Automate it where possible, so staff judgement is not involved.
- If staff ask in person, they ask everyone, as part of a scripted step.
- No incentives for reviews on platforms that prohibit them.
- Service recovery is separate: customers with problems are helped, and their review request is not withheld.
- Every review gets a response, especially critical ones, addressing the specifics.
Hypothetical example:
A cleaning company’s owner has been asking only clients who praise the work to leave a review, and its profile shows a perfect rating from a small number of reviews. An agency sets up an automated text sent to every client the day after each job, with the review link and a separate line inviting anyone with a problem to reply directly. Review volume rises several-fold; the average rating settles slightly below perfect, with a few critical reviews that the owner answers and resolves. Enquiries increase, and the owner notices that prospective clients mention reading how complaints were handled.
Watch for this:
Agencies can be exposed too. If an agency designs or runs a gated review programme, it shares the risk when platforms or regulators act. Put the policy in the client agreement and decline to run programmes that select reviewers by satisfaction.
Responding to reviews is part of the policy
A realistic review profile includes some critical reviews, and how the business responds shapes how prospective customers read them. A calm, specific response that acknowledges the problem and explains what was done often builds more trust than a flawless rating. Agree response standards with clients: reply within a set time, never argue or disclose customer details, and take detailed disputes offline. Where a review breaches platform policies, such as a fake review or one containing abuse, use the platform’s reporting process rather than asking the customer to remove it under pressure.
Timing is the legitimate lever
Businesses can choose when to ask, as long as the choice applies to everyone. Asking shortly after a job is completed, when the experience is fresh, produces more reviews. Asking at a point where problems are likely to have surfaced, rather than before delivery, produces more accurate ones. Making the request easy, with a direct link and a short, personal message, raises response rates without selecting anyone.
Ask every customer, at the same stage, in the same way, preferably automatically; keep service recovery separate from review requests; never offer incentives where platforms prohibit them; respond to every review; and write that policy into client agreements so the line is clear before anyone is tempted to cross it.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.