Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Local SEO
Proximity dominates the map pack. Besides moving the address or opening a location, what has meaningfully expanded a practice’s map radius?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
The honest answer is that nothing reliably “expands the radius” the way a new address does, because there is no radius to expand. Google describes local ranking as a mix of relevance, distance and prominence. Your distance from any given searcher is fixed, so the only levers left are relevance and prominence. Improving those makes you competitive a little further out, where distance counts against you. That is what practitioners see as the radius growing.
The changes with the best case behind them are precise categories, a strong page behind the profile, a steady flow of detailed reviews, and removing spam competitors that sit between you and searchers. The main qualification is that your edge depends heavily on competitor density. In a dense inner-city strip a practice may only dominate a few blocks. In an outer suburb with two competitors, the same profile might hold the pack for kilometres. For demand beyond that edge, organic web results and paid placements usually do more than any profile tweak.
Why the map pack has a coastline, not a circle
Each local search is a fresh ranking of nearby candidates. Distance works like a penalty that grows as the searcher moves away from your address, while relevance and prominence work like a budget that offsets it. You appear wherever your budget beats nearer competitors’ budgets after their smaller distance penalty. So your visible “radius” stretches in directions where competitors are sparse and shrinks where they cluster.
A useful picture: every practice is a hill. Prominence and relevance set its height, and distance is how far the searcher is standing from it. A taller hill can be seen from further away, but only until a nearer hill blocks the view. Google does not publish weights, so treat the analogy as an explanation of why competitor layout shapes your edge, not as a model of the algorithm.
Query type also changes the balance. For implicit searches (“physio”, “dentist near me”), Google works from the searcher’s location. When the searcher names a place (“dentist Subiaco”), relevance to that place matters more and the searcher’s own position matters less. That is why a practice can be invisible on a geogrid for “dentist” two suburbs away, yet appear for “dentist [that suburb]” if it has genuine relevance to it.
What the evidence actually supports
Google’s own help page confirms the three factors, says “More reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking”, and states “There’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google.” Beyond that, the best structured evidence is the 2026 Whitespark Local Search Ranking Factors survey. It is a survey of 47 local search specialists scoring 187 factors, informed by their testing, so it is expert consensus rather than controlled data. Its top local pack factors are primary category, proximity to the searcher, keywords in the business title, a physical address in the city of search, and being open at the time of search, with high ratings, additional categories and the quantity of reviews with text also in the top ten.
Read that list with the question in mind. Proximity and address location are the things you said are off the table. Keywords in the business title only count if they are genuinely part of your real-world name. That leaves categories, hours, reviews and the website as the legitimate levers.
Levers ranked by how much they can move your edge
Lever Why it can extend reach Evidence Risk or cost Primary and secondary categories Category is the strongest relevance match for a query. A practice with a precise category can beat a nearer competitor with a vaguer one. Ranked first in the 2026 survey; widely reported in practitioner tests Changing the primary category can cost visibility on other queries. Grid-scan before and after. The page the profile links to A strong, relevant page (often the homepage for single-location practices) supports relevance and prominence for the listing Practitioner observation; on-page signals remain a substantial category in the survey Low. Test by switching the linked URL and watching the grid. Review flow with detailed text Prominence, plus review text that mentions services people search for Google’s help page; review signals among the largest increases in the 2026 survey Never incentivise or gate reviews. Regulated professions should check rules on soliciting and republishing testimonials. Accurate, longer opening hours Being open at the time of search ranked fifth in the survey, so you may appear further out when nearer competitors are closed Survey consensus Only list hours you actually keep. It helps at certain times rather than across the day. Removing competitor spam Fake listings and keyword-stuffed names block you. When they are removed, your visible edge often grows without you changing anything. Keyword-rich names rank third in the survey, which is why the spam works Time-consuming; use suggested edits and Google’s redressal complaint form with evidence Links and citations General prominence and the website’s own strength Survey says citations continue to decline slightly Diminishing returns once core citations are consistent Practitioner profiles: more listings, same distance
For medical, dental, legal and allied health practices, Google’s guidelines have long allowed separate profiles for public-facing individual practitioners, with restrictions for solo practitioners. A practitioner profile does not change distance, but it adds a listing with its own category. An orthodontist’s profile can compete for orthodontic queries while the practice profile holds general dental queries. The risks are that your own profiles compete with each other and that a departing practitioner’s profile becomes an administrative problem. Check the current practitioner rules before creating them.
What I would not expect to help
Service area settings on a storefront practice: there is no documented ranking effect, and the 2026 survey flags service areas set larger than about two hours’ driving distance as a suspension risk. GBP posts and adding more photos are worth doing for the people who view the profile, but I would not expect either to move the edge meaningfully. Anything behavioural that you fake, such as click or direction-request manipulation, is spam, and the survey’s growing weighting for behavioural signals is a reason to earn real engagement, not to simulate it.
Watch for this:
“Opening a location” at a virtual office or co-working desk, adding keywords to a business name that does not use them in the real world, or moving the map pin away from the true entrance can all look like quick radius wins. They violate Google’s Business Profile guidelines and put the whole listing at risk of suspension. Correcting a genuinely misplaced pin is fine; the survey lists proper pin placement in its top ten.
Where the demand beyond your edge actually goes
For searchers well outside your natural pack area, three channels matter more than profile work:
- Organic web results. Organic rankings for “[service] [suburb]” queries are far less bound to proximity than the pack. Service pages and area pages with real local substance (who you treat from there, parking and transport, local referral partners) can rank well beyond the pack’s edge. Thin suburb-swapped pages are doorway pages under Google’s spam policies and tend not to last.
- Paid placements. Google Ads with location assets can appear in Maps, and Local Services Ads cover some categories and countries. Google is explicit that you cannot pay for better local ranking, so treat this as a separate channel, not a ranking lever.
- Conversational map queries. Ask Maps (Gemini in Google Maps) expanded to English globally in August 2026, with some features still US-only. Longer queries such as “dentist good with anxious kids near Leederville” plausibly lean harder on review content, attributes and website detail. Google has not documented how Ask Maps selects businesses, so treat this as a reason to keep reviews and attributes detailed, not as a separate tactic.
Hypothetical example:
A physiotherapy practice runs a geogrid for “physio” and holds the top three only within about 1.5 km, where six competitors cluster. For “sports physio”, its top-three area stretches much further, because few nearby competitors have a sports-related category or a proper sports injury page. The lesson is that reach is query-specific. The cheapest gains usually come from queries where relevance is scarce among nearby competitors, not from the head term everyone is fighting over.
How to tell whether anything actually expanded reach
- Run geogrid scans on a fixed grid, fixed keyword set, and the same day and time each week. Hours affect ranking, so a Tuesday 10am scan and a Saturday 6pm scan are not comparable. Take several baseline scans first to see normal variation.
- Segment keywords into implicit, “near me” and explicit-suburb queries. They move for different reasons.
- Log competitor changes. If a nearby competitor is suspended, moves or closes, your grid improves without any change on your side.
- Remember that grid tools simulate searcher locations. They are a sample, not a record of what real patients saw.
- Measure the outcome that matters: new-client or new-patient postcodes from your booking or practice management system, before and after. If the radius genuinely grew, bookings from outer suburbs should grow with it.
If this were my practice, I would work in this order: audit categories against the grid for each service query, strengthen the linked page and build genuine service pages, set up a steady review request process that produces detailed reviews, clear out spam competitors with evidence, and then cover demand beyond the edge with organic suburb and service pages plus paid. Judge every step by where new patients come from, not by how green the grid looks.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.