Discussion
  • Local SEO

Hotels compete with OTAs and metasearch in local and AI results. Is fighting for direct visibility worth it, and what has worked?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    Fighting for direct visibility is worth it, but only on the ground a hotel can realistically win: brand searches, its own Business Profile, Google’s hotel results through direct booking links, and specific queries about the property. Generic city searches belong to OTAs and metasearch, and trying to outrank them there is usually wasted effort. The prize is margin. Every booking moved from an OTA to direct saves the commission and gives the hotel the guest relationship, so even a modest shift in the share of guests booking direct can justify the work. What has worked is making the direct option visible where guests are already comparing prices, and making it better than the OTA offer.

    Where hotels can and cannot compete

    Surface Can a hotel compete? How
    Generic “hotels in [city]” results Rarely Not worth the effort for most hotels
    Hotel name searches Yes Strong website, brand result control, direct rates visible
    Business Profile and hotel results in Google Yes Free booking links and rate feeds through a connectivity partner; complete profile
    Specific queries (“hotel with pool near [landmark]”) Sometimes Detailed pages on facilities, rooms and location
    AI trip planning answers Partly Accurate, consistent facts across the website, profile and listings; strong reviews

    What has worked

    1. Getting the direct rate into Google’s hotel results. Hotels whose connectivity partner supports free booking links can show their own rate alongside OTA rates in the hotel price list. Guests comparing prices then see the direct option at the point of decision.
    2. A better direct offer. Rate parity agreements often limit price differences, but perks such as breakfast, flexible cancellation, room upgrades or late checkout can make direct booking the better deal. State them clearly on the site and in the profile.
    3. Protecting brand searches. OTAs and metasearch sites often appear for a hotel’s own name. A fast site, a complete Business Profile, and, where contracts allow, brand-term protection in paid search help keep brand searchers on the direct path.
    4. A booking engine that converts. A slow, confusing booking flow sends guests back to the OTA they trust. Mobile speed, clear pricing and few steps matter as much as visibility.
    5. Consistent facts everywhere. Room types, facilities, policies and photos should match across the website, Business Profile and OTA listings, since guests and assistants compare them.

    AI and local results

    AI trip planners and local AI features draw on Google’s hotel data, Business Profiles, reviews and OTA listings. A hotel cannot control which booking option an assistant suggests, but it can make sure the facts the assistant uses are complete and accurate, and that its own site is the clearest source of detail. Reviews that mention specific strengths, such as quiet rooms, family facilities or a location near a venue, give AI summaries material that matches guests’ requests.

    Hypothetical example:

    A 60-room independent hotel receives most bookings through two OTAs. It switches to a booking engine and connectivity partner that support Google’s free booking links, adds a direct-booking perk of free breakfast and flexible cancellation, rewrites room pages with sizes, views and accessibility details, and updates its Business Profile. Within a season, its direct rate appears in Google’s hotel price list with the perk highlighted, brand searchers book direct more often, and the share of direct bookings rises noticeably. Generic city rankings do not change, and the hotel stops trying to influence them.

    Measure the margin, not the traffic

    • Share of bookings by channel, and commission paid, month by month.
    • Direct bookings from Google hotel results and the Business Profile.
    • Conversion rate of the booking engine, especially on mobile.
    • Brand search clicks to the hotel site versus OTAs, where you can observe them.
    • Repeat guests booking direct after a first OTA stay.

    Watch for this:

    OTA contracts can include rate parity clauses and restrictions on how hotels advertise. Check the terms before promoting lower direct prices; perks and flexible conditions are usually safer ways to make direct booking attractive.

    Metasearch beyond Google

    Google’s hotel results are the largest comparison surface for many hotels, but not the only one. Metasearch and review platforms such as Tripadvisor and trivago, and regional equivalents in some markets, also show price comparisons, and some let hotels show a direct rate through their connectivity providers. Whether paid participation is worth it depends on the hotel’s margin, the platform’s share of its guests’ research, and how much direct bookings actually increase. Start with the free options, including Google’s free booking links and complete, accurate listings, measure the direct bookings they produce, and add paid metasearch only where the numbers show a return after costs.

    The OTA relationship is not the enemy

    OTAs bring guests the hotel could not reach alone, especially international travellers and first-time visitors. The aim is not to eliminate them but to change the mix: let OTAs deliver new guests and make the direct channel the obvious choice for guests who have already found the hotel, and for returning guests. Treated that way, direct visibility work complements distribution rather than fighting it.

    Put direct rates where guests compare prices, make the direct offer better rather than just cheaper, protect brand searches, fix the booking engine, and judge the effort by commission saved, not by generic rankings.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.