Discussion starter: a local SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Local SEO
Franchisees control GBP while head office controls the website. Who should own local SEO, and how do you stop duplicate profiles?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Head office should own local SEO as a system, and franchisees should own the local facts only they can keep accurate. In practice, head office holds ownership of every Business Profile, controls the name, categories and website link, builds the location pages, runs reporting and hunts duplicates. Franchisees get manager access to keep hours, services and photos current and to reply to reviews. That split also protects against duplicates, because they tend to appear where access breaks: a new franchisee who can’t get into the old profile, a relocation handled as a new listing, or a head-office upload that doesn’t match a profile a franchisee created years ago.
The qualification is the franchise agreement. Google’s roles decide who can add or remove users and delete a profile, but they don’t lock individual fields. If the agreement is silent on who owns the brand’s profiles and what happens at resale or termination, no Business Profile setting will fix it. Get the contract and the account structure right first; local SEO tactics come after that.
Title and lease: an ownership model that survives resales
Treat each profile like a shop’s title and lease. Head office holds the title, and the franchisee holds the lease. When a franchise changes hands, the lease is reassigned, but the title, the history and the reviews stay with the location. When a franchisee holds the title instead, a resale or a dispute can leave head office locked out, and the incoming operator’s quickest fix is to create a new profile. That is one way a single location ends up with two profiles.
Google’s roles map onto this. A profile can have several owners but only one primary owner. Owners have full control, including adding or removing users and deleting the profile. Managers have mostly the same access, except that they can’t add or remove users or remove the profile. Managers can still edit business information, hours, phone numbers and URLs, so the role alone won’t stop a franchisee renaming the profile or pointing its website link at a personal site. Monitoring and the contract have to cover that gap.
A workable structure looks like this:
- Primary ownership sits in a head-office account that isn’t tied to one employee, with a second head-office owner as backup.
- Profiles are organised in business groups, so head office can see and manage the whole network in one place.
- Every profile carries a store code that matches the location’s ID in head office’s location master.
- Each franchisee is a manager of their own locations only.
Who does what
Task Head office Franchisee Ownership and user access Primary owner plus a backup owner; adds and removes managers Manager access for own locations Business name and categories Decides, and checks weekly for changes No changes without approval Website link and location page Builds one page per location and sets the profile’s website link to it Supplies local content: team, recent jobs, local proof Phone routing Sets the policy Answers the calls Hours, holiday hours, services, attributes Monitors for gaps Keeps them current Photos Sets standards and supplies brand images Adds real photos of the premises, team and work Reviews Provides a compliant request system, reply guidance and escalation rules Asks every customer the same way and replies promptly Posts and offers National campaigns Local events and offers within brand rules Local links and sponsorships Vets and records them Finds them through local relationships Duplicate checks and reporting Owns Flags anything odd Several of those splits follow Google’s own guidelines. A chain’s locations must use the same name unless a location’s real-world name consistently differs, and locations must share a category if they provide the same service. Google also asks for a phone number that connects to the individual location, or a website that represents it, and prefers a local number to a central call centre helpline where possible. Name and category decisions therefore belong with whoever sees the whole network, and the location’s own page on the head-office site is the natural target for the website link.
Networks differ in how much local marketing franchisees fund and run. Where franchisees pay for it, give them more say over posts, offers and local link building, but not over ownership, naming or the website link. Those are brand assets, and losing one at a resale can undo years of reviews and history. One task has dropped off the list entirely: Business Profile Q&A was removed starting in late 2025, without a formal Google announcement, so it no longer needs an owner.
Where duplicate profiles come from
- Resales and terminations. The outgoing franchisee keeps the login, and the new operator creates a fresh profile.
- Relocations handled as new listings instead of an address change on the existing profile.
- Head-office bulk uploads that don’t get matched to profiles franchisees created earlier, for example because the name or address is formatted differently.
- Service-area franchisees multiplying profiles to appear in more suburbs, sometimes at a home address or a virtual office.
- Conversions into the network. An independent business joins and keeps its old profile alongside a new branded one.
- Practitioner profiles in networks built around individuals, such as real estate or financial advice. Google’s guidelines allow an individual practitioner a dedicated profile when they work in a public-facing role and can be contacted at the verified location during stated hours. These aren’t duplicates, but they need the same ownership rules.
The same guidelines say not to create more than one profile for each location, whether in a single account or across several, and warn that not following the guidelines can lead to changes to the business information or, in some cases, its removal from Google. For service-area businesses, they say to hide the address, keep the overall service area within about two hours’ driving time of where the business is based, and not to list a virtual office unless it’s staffed during business hours. A franchise territory map doesn’t change any of that: one staffed base, one profile, and a service area that fits the guideline.
Stopping new duplicates
- One location master. Head office keeps the record for every location: name, address, phone, hours, categories, store code and the profile it maps to. Every profile matches one row.
- Access before creation. The operations manual says nobody creates a profile for an existing location. If access is lost, request it through Google’s ownership process instead.
- Resale, relocation and closure steps. At a resale, head office removes the outgoing manager and adds the incoming one on handover day. A relocation is an address change on the existing profile, with re-verification if Google asks for it. A closure is marked as permanently closed.
- A contract clause. Brand profiles and location pages belong to head office, franchisees don’t create profiles or websites using the brand name, and both sides cooperate on transfers. Have a franchise lawyer draft it for your jurisdiction.
- Monitoring. Compare each profile’s name, categories, website link, phone and address against the master every week, using the Business Profile APIs or a listing management tool. Add a monthly Maps search for the brand in each territory to catch profiles outside your account.
Cleaning up the duplicates you already have
- Find them. Search Maps for the brand in every territory, including old addresses and former franchisee names, and list any unverified or suspended profiles in your business groups.
- Choose the survivor. Keep the profile with the correct address, the longer history and the reviews. Don’t assume reviews will move to whichever profile you keep, so choose based on where they sit, not on which account is easiest to get into.
- Get access, then resolve. If a franchisee or former franchisee owns the duplicate, request access first, then ask Business Profile support to merge or remove it. Don’t rename a duplicate into a different location: its reviews and history describe the old place.
- Record the fix in the location master, so the next bulk upload doesn’t recreate it.
Hypothetical example:
A 45-location home services franchise audits Maps and finds 54 profiles. Nine franchisees created profiles in personal accounts before head office had a process, and four of those locations also have a head-office profile from a bulk upload. Three resold territories each have a dormant profile under the previous owner that holds most of the reviews. Two franchisees run a second profile at a home address to reach more suburbs. Head office requests access to every profile it doesn’t own, keeps the one with the reviews wherever there is a pair and asks support to merge or remove the other, removes the home-address profiles, and sets each remaining service area within the guideline. It then adds each franchisee as a manager of their own location and writes the resale steps into the operations manual, so the problem doesn’t regrow.
What head office should report for each location
Metric Source Owner Profile fields matching the location master Weekly comparison Head office Duplicate or unowned profiles found Monthly audit Head office Calls, direction requests and website clicks from the profile Business Profile performance data Shared Location page organic sessions and leads GA4 and Search Console, with a tagged website link on each profile Head office Review volume, rating and reply time Profile data Franchisee If I were setting this up for a franchise network, I would start with the contract clause and an ownership sweep, not with rankings. Once head office owns every profile, franchisees manage their own, and each profile maps to one row in the location master, duplicates become an exception caught in a weekly report instead of a clean-up project every time a territory changes hands.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.