Discussion starter: an ecommerce SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- eCommerce SEO
For ‘best X’ queries, can a product listing page compete, or do you need an editorial buying guide that links into the category?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
For most “best X” queries a plain product listing page struggles, because the searcher wants a judgement, not a catalogue. Look at the results for your target queries and you will usually see editorial reviews, comparison articles, forum threads and videos, with shopping units alongside. A standard category grid matches none of those formats. What competes is either an editorial buying guide that makes clear recommendations and links into the category, or a hybrid page that combines a short editorial layer of top picks with a curated product grid. Which one depends on what the results reward and how much genuine insight the retailer can add.
Start by reading the results page
The results for “best X” vary by category, and the right format follows from them.
- Mostly editorial reviews and forums: the query is evaluative. A buying guide with real recommendations has a chance; a product grid does not.
- A mix of reviews and retailer pages: hybrid pages can work, especially for categories where retailers are trusted to curate, such as specialist outdoor, audio or cycling retailers.
- Mostly shopping units and retailer category pages: the query behaves almost like a category query. A well-curated category page, sorted by rating or sales, can rank.
- AI Overviews present: the answer often cites review sites and forums. A retailer page is more likely to be cited if it contains something those sources do not, such as sales or returns data.
The three options compared
Format Fits the intent Converts Main risk Product listing page sorted by rating Weakly Well, for the traffic it gets Rarely ranks for evaluative queries Hybrid: top picks with reasons, then a curated grid Reasonably Well Picks that read as merchandising rather than judgement Editorial buying guide linking into the category Strongly Indirectly, through links to products and category Needs real expertise; conversion is attributed elsewhere What a retailer can offer that review sites cannot
Retailers usually cannot claim independence, and most do not test products the way a dedicated reviewer does. But they hold information that nobody else has, and that is what makes their guides worth ranking and citing:
- What customers actually buy and keep: best sellers, and products with low return rates.
- Why products get returned: sizing, compatibility, durability. That is valuable buying advice.
- Review themes across thousands of verified purchases, summarised honestly.
- Staff expertise: fitters, technicians, buyers who handle the products daily.
- Which products suit which uses, based on customer questions and support conversations.
A buying guide built on that information has something to say. One that paraphrases manufacturer descriptions does not.
Credibility rules for retailer “best” pages
Google’s guidance on reviews asks for evidence of expertise and first-hand experience, explanations of what sets products apart, and honest coverage of drawbacks. Retailers can meet that standard if they are transparent. Say how picks were chosen, include a drawback for each pick, and do not recommend only your highest-margin products. If the guide recommends products you do not stock, or points out that a cheaper option suits most people, readers notice and trust the rest more.
Watch for this:
A buying guide and a category page targeting the same “best X” query will compete. Decide which page owns the evaluative query (usually the guide or hybrid page) and which owns the category query (“men’s running shoes”), and link between them so each supports the other.
How the pieces connect
- The buying guide or hybrid page targets “best X” and related evaluative queries.
- Each recommendation links to its product page, and the guide links to the category with filters relevant to the advice (for example “wide fit” or “trail”).
- The category page links back to the guide near the top (“Not sure what to choose? Read our guide”).
- Product pages link to the guide where the guide recommends them.
Hypothetical example:
A specialist running retailer targets “best running shoes for flat feet”. The results show review sites, a forum thread and a video. The retailer builds a hybrid page: an introduction from its gait analysis team, five picks with who each suits and one drawback each, a short explanation of why some popular models are returned for this foot type, and then a filtered grid of stability shoes. The page ranks on page one within a few months, gets cited in an AI Overview for the statement about return reasons, and sends most of its visitors to product pages. Revenue is attributed to product pages in last-click reports, so the team tracks assisted revenue from the guide separately.
When a category page can win anyway
There are exceptions worth knowing. Very large retailers with strong brand trust sometimes rank category pages for “best X” queries, particularly when the page has a visible “best sellers” or “top rated” module and many reviews. Queries with a price qualifier, such as “best X under £100”, often behave more like category queries, because the searcher is closer to buying and wants to see options. And in some categories the results simply favour shopping units and retailers. In those cases, a category page with a well-labelled “top rated” sort, a short introduction explaining how ratings are gathered, and strong review content can compete. Check the results for each query family rather than applying one rule across the catalogue.
Keep guides current without chasing the year
“Best X” content goes stale quickly as products change. Put the date the guide was last reviewed on the page, update recommendations when products are discontinued or replaced, and keep the URL stable rather than creating a new URL each year. Adding the current year to the title can help click-through, but only if the content was genuinely reviewed that year. A guide with this year in its title and last year’s discontinued products in its picks damages trust quickly, and readers notice.
Measure it fairly
Buying guides and hybrid pages sit earlier in the journey than category pages, so last-click revenue understates them. Measure clicks from the guide to product and category pages, assisted revenue, and the revenue of sessions that viewed the guide. Compare the category’s total organic revenue before and after the guide launched, not only the guide’s own numbers. If the category’s revenue rises while the guide itself shows little direct revenue, the guide is doing its job.
Check the results first; if they are editorial, build a genuine buying guide or hybrid page using the data only you have, link it tightly into the category, and judge it on the category’s performance rather than its own last-click revenue.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.