Discussion starter: an ecommerce SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- eCommerce SEO
Model A versus model B comparison pages for your own products: do they win comparison queries, or cannibalise the product pages?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
Niraj Raut
Comparison pages for your own models usually win comparison queries without cannibalising product pages, because the two serve different searches. “[Model A] vs [Model B]” is a distinct query from the searcher who wants to buy Model A, and a page that compares the two directly answers it better than either product page can. The risk of cannibalisation is low when product pages are clearly focused on their product and the comparison page is clearly about the comparison, and when both link to each other. Comparison pages also help conversion, since shoppers deciding between two of your models are already close to buying. The main mistake is creating comparisons for every possible pair, most of which nobody searches for.
Why the pages serve different intents
Query Intent Best page “[Model A]” Find or buy that model Product page “[Model A] price” or “[Model A] specs” Details about that model Product page “[Model A] vs [Model B]” Choose between two models Comparison page “Which [brand] model should I buy” Choose within the range Range comparison or buying guide What makes a good comparison page
- A clear recommendation of who each model suits, stated in the opening lines.
- A side-by-side table of the specifications that differ, not every specification.
- Plain explanation of what the differences mean in use.
- Prices, or how pricing differs, kept current.
- Links to both product pages and a buy option for each.
- Honest notes on trade-offs, such as the cheaper model lacking a feature some buyers need.
Choosing which comparisons to build
- Check search demand for “[Model A] vs [Model B]” pairs in keyword tools and Search Console.
- Check your site search for comparisons shoppers look for.
- Ask customer service and sales which models customers most often ask to compare.
- Prioritise adjacent models in the range and models replacing older ones.
A range comparison page, covering all models in a series with a “which one is right for you” guide, often covers many pairs better than individual pages for each.
Hypothetical example:
A vacuum brand has four cordless models and notices searches comparing adjacent models and questions to customer service about the differences. It builds three comparison pages for the most searched pairs and a range guide covering all four, each linking to the relevant product pages. The comparison pages rank for their “vs” queries within weeks, product pages keep their positions for model-name searches, and conversion from comparison page visitors is higher than from product page visitors, because they arrive having narrowed their choice. Customer service contacts about model differences fall.
Watch for this:
Generating comparison pages for every combination of models creates many thin pages with no demand, and they can compete with each other. Build pages for the comparisons people actually make, and let a range guide handle the rest.
Comparisons in AI answers
Shoppers increasingly ask assistants which of a brand’s models to choose. Assistants answer from whatever sources explain the differences: reviews, retailer pages, forums and the brand’s own pages. A clear, current comparison page from the brand, with specific differences and honest guidance on who each model suits, is a strong source for those answers, especially for factual details such as specifications and prices. Without it, assistants rely on third-party comparisons that may be outdated or incomplete.
Keep comparisons current
Model ranges change: new models launch, old ones are discontinued, prices move. Tie each comparison page to the product data so specifications and prices update automatically, and review the recommendations when the range changes. When a model is discontinued, update the comparison to point to its successor rather than leaving a page that compares a product no longer on sale.
Signs of cannibalisation to watch for
In Search Console, check whether comparison pages start receiving impressions for single-model queries, or product pages for “vs” queries, and whether positions swap between them. If a comparison page begins ranking for a model’s name, check whether its title and heading focus too heavily on one model; if a product page ranks for a comparison, add a clear link from it to the comparison page. Usually a small adjustment in titles and internal links resolves it.
Build comparison pages for the model pairs people actually compare, make them decisive and honest, link them tightly to both product pages, use a range guide for the rest, and watch Search Console for the rare case of overlap.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.