Discussion
  • eCommerce SEO

Amazon and eBay sellers outrank your own product pages for your own branded SKUs. Fight for those queries, or treat marketplaces as a channel?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: an ecommerce SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    It depends on who the sellers are and what each sale is worth to you. If the listings outranking you are your own marketplace listings, or authorised resellers, the marketplace is a channel doing its job, and the question is margin and customer data rather than rankings. If they are unauthorised or grey-market sellers, the problem is distribution control, and SEO alone will not fix it. In both cases it is worth improving your own product pages, because there are queries and customers a brand site should win, but “outrank Amazon for every SKU” is rarely a realistic or even desirable goal.

    Why marketplaces outrank brand product pages

    Marketplaces have enormous domain strength, thousands of reviews per popular product, competitive prices, fast delivery promises and pages that exactly match “[brand] [model]” queries. Their pages also attract clicks because shoppers trust the checkout. A brand’s own product page often has less review content, a higher price, slower delivery and a thinner description written for the catalogue rather than the searcher. Google is choosing the result it thinks will satisfy the query, and for a shopper ready to buy a specific SKU, that is often a marketplace.

    First, work out whose listings they are

    Who is outranking you What it means Main response
    Your own marketplace store (first-party or as a seller) You still make the sale, minus fees, and lose customer data Channel strategy: decide where you want each customer to buy
    Authorised resellers Partners making sales you approved Coordinate content and pricing; accept overlap
    Unauthorised or grey-market sellers Sales outside your control, possible pricing and quality problems Brand protection programmes, distribution agreements, pricing policy enforcement

    Do the channel maths before fighting

    Compare the contribution margin of a sale on your site with a sale through the marketplace, after fees, fulfilment and advertising. Add the value of owning the customer relationship: repeat purchases, email marketing and warranty registration. For some brands the direct sale is worth much more; for others, marketplace fulfilment and conversion rates narrow the gap. If a marketplace sale is worth nearly as much as a direct one, spending heavily to divert branded SKU traffic may not pay back. If the direct sale is worth far more, investing in your own pages is easier to justify.

    Where your own pages can realistically win

    • Information queries about your products: manuals, compatibility, specifications, spare parts, setup guides and warranty terms. Marketplaces rarely cover these well.
    • New and exclusive products, before marketplaces list them, or products you only sell direct.
    • Bundles, configurations and personalisation not available elsewhere.
    • Shoppers who prefer buying from the manufacturer for warranty or authenticity reasons, if you make those benefits visible.
    • Merchant listings, where your products can appear through Merchant Center free listings alongside marketplace offers.

    Improving the brand product page

    1. Add what only the manufacturer can provide: detailed specifications, compatibility tables, manuals, videos, care instructions, spare parts and genuine answers to common questions.
    2. Collect reviews on your own site through post-purchase requests, and show them clearly. Review volume is one of the marketplace’s biggest advantages.
    3. State direct-purchase benefits near the price: extended warranty, free returns, authenticity, exclusive colours or bundles.
    4. Get the structured data and feed right: Product markup with price, availability and identifiers such as GTIN, plus a Merchant Center feed so your offer appears in shopping surfaces.
    5. Check price competitiveness. If your site is consistently more expensive than marketplaces, shoppers will choose accordingly whatever your rankings.

    Watch for this:

    Some brands try to win by making marketplace listings weaker, for example with poorer images or thinner descriptions. That usually costs sales on the marketplace without moving them to the brand site, and it can breach agreements with retail partners. Differentiate by adding value to your own site, not by degrading the channel.

    Unauthorised sellers are not an SEO problem

    If grey-market or unauthorised sellers dominate your branded SKU results, the fixes sit with legal, sales and distribution teams: marketplace brand protection programmes, tighter distributor agreements, pricing policies where lawful, and action against counterfeits. SEO can support that work by documenting which sellers rank for which SKUs and how prices compare, but a better product page will not remove a seller undercutting you.

    Hypothetical example:

    A kitchen appliance brand sees Amazon and two eBay sellers above its own product pages for most model-number searches. Analysis shows Amazon listings are its own first-party sales, while the eBay sellers are unauthorised and undercutting price. The brand leaves Amazon alone for purchase queries, raises the eBay issue with its distribution team, and rebuilds its product pages with compatibility charts, spare parts, manuals and a two-year direct warranty. Its pages start ranking above marketplaces for “[model] manual”, “[model] replacement parts” and “[model] warranty”, and direct sales grow among buyers who value the warranty, while total revenue across channels holds.

    How to measure the right outcome

    Track your position for branded SKU queries, but judge success on total branded revenue across channels and contribution margin, not on whether your site ranks first. Add direct-channel share of branded sales, the growth of your own customer base, and the number of SKU queries where unauthorised sellers appear in the top results. If the brand site gains share where it offers more, and total revenue holds or grows, the strategy is working even if Amazon still tops most SKU results.

    Treat your own and authorised marketplace listings as a channel, fight unauthorised sellers through distribution and brand protection, and build product pages that win the queries and customers where the manufacturer genuinely offers more.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.