Discussion starter: a B2B and SaaS SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- AI Search
- SaaS SEO
When buyers ask AI assistants for tool recommendations, what has actually moved your product into those lists?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
What tends to move a product into assistants’ recommendation lists is presence in the sources those assistants consult for category questions: independent review platforms, comparison articles on reputable sites, analyst and industry coverage, community discussions, and clear, consistent descriptions of what the product is and who it is for. Assistants that search the web build lists from pages that rank for “best [category]” queries and similar searches; assistants answering from training data reflect what was widely written about products. In both cases, a product that is rarely discussed by others is rarely recommended. The evidence for all of this is practitioner observation and prompt tracking rather than controlled studies, and the lists vary a lot from run to run, but the pattern is consistent enough to plan around.
Where recommendation lists come from
Source type Why it matters What you can do Review and software comparison platforms Rank for category and comparison searches; structured reviews Maintain complete profiles; earn real customer reviews Independent “best tools” articles Often retrieved for recommendation prompts Give reviewers access, data and briefings; earn inclusion on merit Analyst and industry coverage Signals category leadership Engage with analysts relevant to your buyers Community discussions Real users recommending tools to each other Build a product people talk about; participate openly Your own site Defines your category, audience and differences State clearly what the product does, for whom, and how it compares Make your own positioning unambiguous
Assistants often describe products using phrases from their own sites. If your homepage says “the platform for modern teams”, an assistant has little to go on. If it says “project management software for creative agencies of 10 to 200 people, with resource planning and client approvals”, the assistant can match you to a prompt like “best project management tool for a design agency”. Consistent descriptions across your site, review profiles, directories and social profiles reinforce the category and audience association.
Comparison and alternatives pages
Pages comparing your product with named competitors, and “alternatives to [competitor]” pages, are often retrieved for comparison prompts. They work best when they are fair: state where the competitor is stronger, show criteria, and keep details current. Biased comparisons are easy to spot and are less likely to be trusted by readers or cited by systems that try to favour balanced sources.
Measure it with care
- Build a prompt set reflecting how buyers ask: by category, by use case, by company size, by budget, by integration.
- Run prompts repeatedly across the main assistants, because lists vary between runs.
- Record appearance rate and cited sources, not rank position within the list, which is unstable.
- Map sources to action: which review sites, articles and discussions appear, and where you are missing.
Hypothetical example:
A scheduling software company rarely appears when assistants are asked for “best appointment scheduling software for clinics”. Prompt tracking shows the answers citing two software review platforms, three independent comparison articles and a community thread. The company has few reviews on one platform and is absent from the articles. It runs a review request programme with existing clinic customers, offers the article authors demo accounts and a briefing on its clinic-specific features, and rewrites its homepage and clinic page to say plainly who the product is for. Over two quarters, its appearance rate for clinic prompts rises, while prompts for other industries, where it did no work, stay flat.
Watch for this:
Paying for placement in “best tools” lists without disclosure, or publishing lists that rank yourself first while posing as independent, can produce short-term mentions and long-term problems with spam policies, consumer protection rules and trust. The durable route is earning inclusion in sources that are genuinely independent.
Segment the prompts, because lists differ by buyer
Recommendation lists change with the details in the prompt. A product may appear often for “best CRM for small businesses” and rarely for “best CRM for enterprise sales teams”, or appear for one industry and not another. Averaging across all prompts hides where you are strong and where you are absent. Group prompts by the segments you sell to, such as company size, industry, use case and budget, and report appearance rates for each group. That shows where visibility work is needed, and it often reveals that the product is recommended exactly where the business wants to grow least, or not at all where it wants to grow most. Target the independent sources that cover those under-represented segments first.
Product and reputation still decide
AI recommendations reflect what the web says about products. If customers are unhappy, reviewers are critical or the product lags competitors on features buyers care about, visibility work will not overcome it for long. The companies that appear consistently tend to have products people recommend without prompting. Visibility work helps a good product be seen; it rarely rescues a weak one.
Make your positioning explicit, earn presence on the review platforms and independent articles assistants cite, publish fair comparison pages, track appearance rates and sources rather than list positions, and keep improving the product people are being asked to recommend.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.