Discussion
  • Content SEO

UK financial promotion rules restrict comparison claims, yet some unregulated sites make them anyway. How do compliant firms compete in search?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: a YMYL SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    Compliant firms do not win this by matching the claims, and they should not try. They compete by using the room the rules actually leave, by owning the queries where authorisation and first-party product data are real advantages, and by getting their products listed, accurately, on the comparison pages that already rank. The uncomfortable context is that Google’s organic results do not check FCA authorisation. Google Ads runs a financial services verification process for UK advertisers that is tied to FCA authorisation, but Google documents no equivalent check for organic rankings. Compliance is a constraint to design around, not a ranking advantage in itself.

    The main qualification is that “the rules restrict comparison claims” can be read more strictly than the rules are written. The FCA’s comparison rule requires comparisons to be meaningful, fair and balanced. It does not ban them. A firm whose internal policy is “no comparisons at all” has given away queries it could legitimately compete for.

    What the rules restrict, and what they leave open

    The standard running through the FCA’s sourcebooks is that communications must be fair, clear and not misleading. For comparisons, COBS 4.5.6R says that where information compares relevant business, relevant investments or the persons who carry on that business, a firm “must ensure that the comparison is meaningful and presented in a fair and balanced way”. COBS 4.5 applies to information and financial promotions for retail clients in designated investment business, excluding MiFID business, which has its own provisions. The neighbouring rule, COBS 4.5.2R, requires information to be accurate, to give a fair and prominent indication of relevant risks, and not to disguise, diminish or obscure important items, statements or warnings.

    Credit, insurance, mortgages and deposits sit in their own sourcebooks (CONC, ICOBS, MCOB and BCOBS), each with its own version of the fair, clear and not misleading standard, and for retail customers the Consumer Duty’s consumer understanding outcome applies on top. Check the sourcebook for your product rather than assuming the COBS wording carries across.

    Your compliance team makes the call, but a comparison with a stated comparison set, date, data source and criteria is far easier to approve than an unqualified “best”. That is as much a content design problem as a compliance one, and it is the same information a searcher comparing products needs to judge the claim.

    Why non-compliant pages rank anyway

    “Unregulated sites” covers three different situations, and each calls for a different response:

    • Content outside the promotion regime. Genuinely editorial content may not be a financial promotion at all, in which case the promotion rules may not reach it.
    • Approved promotions. An unauthorised business can communicate a financial promotion that an authorised firm has approved. Since February 2024, a firm needs FCA permission, through the regulatory gateway, to approve promotions for unauthorised persons, and the approving firm is responsible for confirming the promotion complies.
    • Breaches. Some publishers are simply in breach, and action against small, anonymous or offshore sites is slow.

    As far as Google documents, its organic ranking systems do not check which of these applies. Google’s spam policies describe manipulative practices such as link spam, scaled content abuse and site reputation abuse; regulatory status is not among them. A page with an unsubstantiated “best” claim can rank on the same signals as any other page, and a compliant page has to beat it on those signals, not on its compliance.

    Where compliant firms can win

    Query class Example Your advantage What to build
    Product facts “1 year fixed rate bond rates”, “[product] fees” You hold the live data; third-party pages can go stale Product pages with current, dated rates, fees and eligibility, and a visible change log
    Eligibility “can I get a loan on a zero-hours contract” You know the real criteria Criteria pages and eligibility checkers that use soft searches where your process supports them
    Mechanics “fixed vs variable mortgage”, “ISA vs general investment account” You can explain how products work without naming competitors Balanced explainers with worked examples and plain risk statements
    Brand checks “[brand] review”, “is [brand] safe”, “[brand] vs [brand]” You can prove authorisation and protection Register links, deposit protection and complaints information, and fair side-by-side comparisons that compliance has approved
    “Best” and “compare” lists “best easy access savings account” Low for your own pages; higher as a product listed on other pages Accurate listings on the comparison platforms that rank, and a methodology page for any list you publish yourself

    For rate-led products, a comparison against a published market benchmark (your rate against a named, dated industry average) can be easier to substantiate than a head-to-head claim about a named competitor, and it still answers the searcher’s real question: is this a good rate?

    Turn compliance into speed

    The operational edge a compliant firm can build is approval speed. A non-compliant affiliate can publish a claim in an hour; you cannot, but you can shrink the gap considerably with a few structures:

    • A claims library: each approved claim with its evidence, data source, date, expiry and owner.
    • Pre-approved components: rate and fee tables fed from the product system, standard risk statements and, for credit, representative examples, so a routine page update does not need a full review.
    • A methodology page for any list or “best” claim: what was compared, the criteria and weighting, the data source and date, and whether commercial relationships affect the order.
    • Review triggers: a rate change, product change or rule change opens a review automatically instead of waiting for someone to notice.
    • An agreed turnaround target with compliance for search-driven changes, measured in days and reported monthly.

    Get listed where comparison queries are answered

    Look at who ranks for your twenty most valuable “best” and “compare” queries. If the results are comparison platforms and publishers rather than providers, the realistic goal is to appear on those pages, with correct data, not to outrank them with your own list. Track the share of those ranking pages that include your product and whether the rate and fees shown are current.

    Be careful with the commercial side. If you supply the copy or approve a partner’s promotion, you take on responsibility for what it says, and the Consumer Duty expects firms to consider customer outcomes across their distribution chain. Routing claims you could not make yourself through a partner is not a clean workaround.

    Handling competitors who break the rules

    Reporting is worth doing, but treat it as hygiene rather than strategy, because it is slow and you do not control the outcome:

    • Misleading or unauthorised financial promotions can be reported to the FCA.
    • Marketing claims outside the FCA regime can fall under the Advertising Standards Authority and general consumer protection law.
    • If the competitor is a third-party section hosted on another site to exploit that site’s ranking signals, Google’s site reputation abuse policy may apply. Google’s August 2026 update changed enforcement inside the EEA; the UK is outside the EEA, where manual actions still apply.
    • Use Google’s spam report for spam tactics such as link schemes or scaled content. It is not a channel for regulatory complaints.

    AI answers repeat the same claims

    AI Overviews and chat assistants can repeat a competitor’s “best” claim or an out-of-date rate. Google’s guide to optimising for generative AI features says this is still SEO and needs no special AI files, special schema or AI-specific rewording, so the same approach applies: clear, current, sourced product facts on crawlable pages. Once a month, check what the main assistants say about your products for your priority queries, log inaccuracies, and correct the pages they draw on where you can identify them. There is no guarantee an assistant will pick up the correction, which is why the log matters: it tells you whether the problem is shrinking.

    What to measure

    KPI Why it matters Where
    Share of top-ranking comparison pages that list your product, with correct data Presence where your own page will not rank Monthly review of your priority “best” and “compare” results
    Clicks and application starts from product-fact and eligibility queries The queries you can realistically own Search Console and your analytics
    Composition of your brand-check results What people find when they check you out before applying Monthly check of “[brand] review” and “is [brand] safe”
    Median days from draft to approval for search-driven changes Speed is the edge compliance can give you Your workflow or ticketing tool
    Inaccurate AI answers about your products, logged and resolved Tracks how far competitors’ claims or stale data spread Monthly prompt log
    AI impressions by page Exposure in Google’s AI features Search generative AI performance report (impressions only)

    The position I would take

    If I were running search for a regulated UK provider, I would stop judging success by whether our own page outranks an affiliate for “best [product]”. I would judge it on three things: whether we own the product-fact, eligibility and brand-check queries; whether we appear, accurately, on the pages that rank for comparison queries; and how many days compliance takes to approve a search-driven change. Under these rules, fast, substantiated claims are a more realistic edge than big ones.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.