Discussion starter: a digital PR question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Digital PR
Scholarship pages and resource links on .edu or .ac domains: still worth pursuing, or so abused that they’re discounted?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
The short answer: scholarship pages are the weakest way to get a university link, and I would not run one as a link tactic in 2026. Links from.edu,.ac.uk or.edu.au domains carry no special weight because of the domain ending. Google has said so for years. What gives any link value is whether the linking page is a real, used resource and whether someone made an editorial choice to link.
A scholarship listing usually fails both tests. It is a financial aid page listing outside offers of money, often next to injury lawyers, casinos and SaaS tools, and a scholarship created mainly to get that link sits close to Google’s definition of buying links. University links earned through research, data, careers services and genuine resources are still worth having, but for relevance, referral and brand reasons, not the TLD.
Where the “.edu links are powerful” belief came from
University domains are old, large and heavily linked, so pages on them often sit close to a lot of link equity. Early link builders saw that correlation and credited the TLD. Google’s position has been consistent that the TLD itself is not the reason: coverage from 2008 reports Google’s John Mueller saying EDU links are not better links by virtue of the domain, and Search Engine Journal’s review of the claim reaches the same conclusion in its ranking factor series.
A useful way to picture it: a reference letter printed on university letterhead is worth what the person who signed it knows about you. A research group linking to your dataset is a signed letter. A scholarship listing is closer to letterhead with no signature: the financial aid office checked that your offer exists, not that your business is any good.
The technical version: link-based signals depend on the importance of the linking page, the relevance of its context, and whether the link looks editorially given. A deep financial aid page with 200 unrelated outbound links is weak on all three, whatever domain it lives on.
Why scholarship links are a poor bet now
1. The policy fit is uncomfortable
Google’s spam policies define link spam as “the practice of creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings”, and list buying or selling links for ranking purposes, including exchanging money, goods or services for links. The policy page does not name scholarships. But a scholarship that exists mainly to earn a link is money exchanged for a link, routed through a student. If the scholarship would exist anyway and the link is incidental, the intent is different; that is the honest test to apply.
2. The pattern is easy to classify
Scholarship pages look alike across thousands of institutions: a list of “[Company] Scholarship” entries from unrelated commercial businesses, each linking to a landing page on the sponsor’s site that exists only for the scholarship. When Google announced its December 2022 link spam update, it said SpamBrain was being used to detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links, and that affected links would be neutralised. There is no public confirmation that scholarship pages are specifically targeted, but a template this uniform is the kind of pattern link classifiers are built to find.
3. Discounting is invisible
Google mostly ignores links it does not trust rather than penalising the site. That means a scholarship link can be worth nothing and you will never be told. The absence of a penalty is not evidence the link is working.
4. The context is off-topic, and the listing is not yours
Search Engine Journal’s piece on why scholarship link building fails (2019) makes the relevance argument: a scholarship page makes the sponsor relevant to scholarships, not to what it sells. The listing is also controlled by the university, which can remove it, add nofollow or change its criteria at any time without telling you. Check the current state of any listing before counting it, rather than relying on what it looked like at launch.
5. The real cost is not the prize money
You have to run an application process, judge entries, pay the award, handle tax and legal questions, and publish winners. A scholarship that is quietly never awarded is a reputational problem that a journalist or a disappointed student can find.
The other reason university domains attract suspicion
Many university sites have hosted third-party commercial content on subfolders, subdomains or abandoned student blogs, from coupon pages to gambling reviews. Google’s site reputation abuse policy uses an educational site hosting third-party payday loan reviews as one of its examples. In August 2026 Google updated that policy: in the EEA the manual action impact no longer applies, but the affected section may be separated in Google’s systems so it ranks independently, while manual actions still apply outside the EEA.
The link building implication: if a section of a university site can be treated separately from the institution’s core content, links from that section should not be assumed to carry the university’s reputation. “Edu link packages” sold through student blogs or hijacked subdomains are the worst version of this whole category.
University links that are still worth earning
Link type How it is earned Likely value Risk Research citation or dataset reference Publishing original data, methods or tools that academics use High relevance, durable, often cited again elsewhere Low Library research guides Being genuinely the best free resource on a subject Modest link value, real referral traffic from students Low Careers services and employer pages Graduate programs, internships, relationships with the careers office Brand, recruitment, topical association Low Faculty, lab or course pages Collaboration, guest lectures, disclosed research sponsorship High topical relevance Low; expect sponsored links to be qualified Student services resources Local housing, health, accessibility or transport services near campus Local relevance and referrals Low to moderate Club, event and hackathon sponsorship Paying to sponsor Brand exposure; ranking value only if the link is qualified and you do not rely on it Low if qualified with rel="sponsored"Scholarship listings Funding a scholarship to get listed Low and uncertain; can be removed or qualified at any time Moderate (link scheme exposure, admin cost) Student blogs, abused subdomains, “edu packages” Buying Likely zero High Google’s spam policies say paid links are not a violation when they are qualified with
rel="nofollow"orrel="sponsored". That is the right frame for sponsorships: pay for the audience and the association, and treat any ranking effect as a bonus you do not count on.A quick test for any specific university link
- Would a student or researcher actually use this page? Check whether it is linked from the site’s navigation, ranks for anything, and has been updated in the last year or two.
- Is the outbound link list curated and topical, or a long list of unrelated commercial offers?
- Did someone at the institution make an editorial judgement about your content, or only confirm that an offer exists?
- Is the page on the institution’s core site, or on a subdomain or folder that hosts third-party content?
- Would you still want the link if it were qualified with
rel="sponsored"? If the answer is no, you are buying ranking, not audience.
If you already have scholarship links, or want to run one anyway
Existing scholarship links rarely justify a disavow. Google’s guidance frames the disavow tool for sites with a considerable number of spammy or artificial links that have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. A handful of scholarship listings is more likely being ignored than counted against you. If you have a large, obviously bought pattern (hundreds of listings, exact-match anchors, a landing page that exists only for the links), that changes the calculation.
If there is a real business reason for a scholarship (recruiting graduates in your field, community presence, a founder’s connection to a program), run it properly: fund it through a relevant faculty rather than a generic aid list, pay and publicise winners, keep it running for years, and accept whatever link attribute the university chooses.
Hypothetical example:
A civil engineering consultancy funds an annual prize through a university’s engineering faculty and hosts the winner for a paid internship. The faculty news page announces the winner and links to the firm; the careers office lists the internship. Those links are topical, editorially given and tied to something real. Compare a personal injury firm funding a AUD 1,000 “essay scholarship” listed on 150 unrelated financial aid pages. The first is a relationship that produces links. The second is a link purchase with extra administration.
What would change this view
Link value from a single domain cannot be cleanly isolated on one site: rankings move for too many other reasons, and a discounted link produces no signal. If you want evidence, track the target page against comparable pages that received no new links over the same period, and weigh referral traffic, applications and branded search alongside rankings. A Google statement endorsing scholarship programs, or a controlled comparison across several similar sites, would change my position. Anecdotes of a ranking jump after a scholarship campaign would not, because the campaign usually ships with other link building and content work.
My practical position: spend the scholarship budget on something a university would link to without being paid. Original data, a genuinely useful tool, or a real relationship with a faculty or careers office will produce fewer links, but they are links that a spam classifier and a human reviewer would both recognise as earned.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.