Discussion starter: a digital PR question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Digital PR
Nofollow and sponsored links from major news sites: have you seen evidence they pass any value as hints?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Google has treated
nofollow,sponsoredandugcas hints rather than strict instructions since 2019, which means it can choose to use such links for ranking or discovery. What nobody outside Google can show is when it does, or how much value such a link passes when it does. There is no clean public evidence isolating the ranking effect of a nofollow link from a major news site. What is clear is that these links often bring value that has nothing to do with the attribute: referral traffic, brand exposure, discovery by other journalists and writers who then link normally, and mentions that feed how assistants describe your brand. Value them for those reasons, and do not buy sponsored placements expecting ranking benefit.What “hint” means in practice
When Google announced the change, it said link attributes would be treated as hints about the nature of the link, to be considered along with other signals, rather than as directives to ignore the link. Google has not said which nofollow links it uses or how. It is reasonable to assume that editorially placed links on reputable sites, where the attribute was applied as a blanket policy, are more likely to be considered than links in comments or paid placements. It is equally reasonable to assume that sponsored links are rarely, if ever, allowed to pass ranking value, since that would undermine the purpose of the attribute.
The value you can actually see
Benefit How to measure it Referral traffic Sessions and conversions from the linking article Brand exposure Branded search around publication; mentions Secondary links New referring domains citing the same story or data in the following weeks Journalist discovery Enquiries and coverage that cite the original article AI visibility Whether assistants start mentioning or citing your brand for related prompts Secondary links are often the largest search benefit. A story in a major outlet is read by other writers, bloggers and researchers, some of whom link to your site directly with followed links. The nofollow link started a chain that the attribute does not control.
Why you cannot isolate the effect
A major news link rarely arrives alone. Coverage usually comes with syndication, social sharing, secondary coverage and brand searches. Rankings may rise afterwards, but separating the effect of the nofollow link itself from everything else it caused is not possible with public data. Case studies claiming to show nofollow links “passing value” usually cannot rule out the other effects.
Hypothetical example:
A fintech company’s survey is covered by a national newspaper with a nofollow link. Over the next month, the article sends a few thousand visitors, branded searches rise, and fourteen other sites, including trade publications and personal finance blogs, cite the survey with followed links. The survey page begins to rank for related statistics queries. The company cannot tell how much of that came from the newspaper link itself; it can tell that the coverage started everything, and it plans its PR around earning more of it.
What not to do
- Do not ask journalists to remove nofollow attributes; it signals you care about links more than the story, and most outlets will not change policy.
- Do not buy sponsored articles on news sites expecting ranking gains; buy them only if the audience is worth reaching.
- Do not disavow nofollow links; there is no reason to.
- Do not dismiss coverage in PR reporting because the link is nofollow; report its full effects.
Watch for this:
Some link sellers now market “high authority nofollow links” on news sites, arguing that Google treats them as hints. Paid placements are exactly what the
sponsoredattribute exists for, and paying for placement in the hope of ranking value is a link scheme whatever attribute the link carries.Why editorial nofollow is still worth chasing
Many major publishers apply nofollow or sponsored attributes to all external links as policy, regardless of editorial merit. That means some of the most valuable coverage a brand can earn will never carry a followed link. Excluding those outlets from PR targets because of the attribute would mean ignoring the audiences, credibility and secondary coverage that make them valuable. The better filter is editorial: would a mention in this publication reach people you want to reach, and would other writers treat it as a reason to cite you? If yes, pursue it whatever the link attribute. Followed links then tend to arrive from the secondary coverage, which is exactly where you want them to come from.
How to report these links
In PR and SEO reports, list coverage by outlet with the link attribute noted, but measure it by outcomes: referral sessions, branded search, secondary links, enquiries and AI mentions. That gives a truer picture of what the coverage achieved than a count of followed links, and it keeps the team focused on earning coverage people read.
Treat nofollow and sponsored links from major outlets as valuable for exposure, referrals and the followed links they inspire, accept that any direct ranking value is unknowable, and never pay for placements on the theory that a hint might count.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.