Discussion
  • Content SEO

Hospital and government health sites dominate many queries. What can independent health publishers realistically do?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: a YMYL SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    Realistically: stop competing with hospitals and health departments on the queries those institutions exist to answer, and build where they are structurally weak. That means practical questions about living with a condition, product and service decisions, costs and access in your own health system, new research explained quickly, and specific groups that general-population pages serve poorly. On definitional queries (“what is sleep apnoea”, “symptoms of coeliac disease”) the ceiling for an independent publisher is low, and AI Overviews now answer many of those questions on the results page as well.

    The main qualification is that “independent” covers very different businesses. A clinician-led publisher with genuine reviewers and a defined audience can compete on more queries than a content site run on freelance writers and affiliate links. For both, the realistic goal is not outranking institutions. It is choosing query classes where you can offer something their pages cannot, and building an audience that chooses you directly.

    Why institutions win the head terms

    Google’s guidance on helpful, reliable content says E-E-A-T is not a specific ranking factor, but that its systems use a mix of factors that can identify content with good E-E-A-T, that trust is the most important part, and that its systems give even more weight to content aligning with strong E-E-A-T on topics that could significantly affect people’s health, financial stability or safety. A hospital or health department brings trust evidence a small publisher cannot manufacture quickly: named clinicians, institutional reputation, citations from other health bodies and years of links.

    On a definitional query, that evidence breaks the tie, because the content itself is close to identical. The same guidance asks whether a page provides substantial value compared with other pages in search results. A careful rewrite of what the health department’s page already says struggles to pass that test however well it is edited, because the searcher gains little they could not get from the institution.

    AI features squeeze the head terms further, although the data is patchy. Search Engine Journal’s March 2026 report on Google’s health search changes cites Ahrefs data in which medical YMYL queries triggered AI Overviews 44.1% of the time, and an SE Ranking study of German health queries in which YouTube was the most-cited domain in health AI Overviews, ahead of medical and government sites. Those are single datasets with their own methods, but the second is a useful reminder that AI citation is not a copy of the institutional ranking order.

    The same report carries a warning about building strategy on SERP features. “What People Suggest”, which organised health perspectives from online discussions on US mobile results, was removed in March 2026. A Google spokesperson described the removal as part of a broader simplification of the results page and said it was unrelated to the feature’s quality or safety. Whatever the reason, the feature that gave lived experience a dedicated slot on health results has gone, and first-hand content now has to earn its place in ordinary results.

    Where independent publishers can realistically compete

    Institutions have sound reasons not to publish some kinds of content. Public bodies generally avoid recommending products, hospitals describe their own services, changes go through clinical and legal review, and pages are written for a general population in one jurisdiction. Each of those constraints leaves a gap.

    Query class Why institutional pages leave room What a strong independent page adds
    Living with a condition: work, travel, food, exercise, caring Institutional pages centre on diagnosis and treatment First-hand, clinician-checked practical detail, such as flying with a CPAP machine or managing shift work with diabetes
    Product and service decisions Public bodies generally avoid comparing brands, devices or apps Hands-on testing, transparent methods and disclosed commercial relationships
    Costs and access in your health system Government pages explain the rules; hospitals cover only their own services Worked examples of rebates, out-of-pocket costs, wait times and referral pathways
    New research explained Pages follow review cycles, so new findings can take time to appear Fast, careful explainers that state what a study does and does not show
    Specific groups and edge cases Written for the average patient Depth for a defined audience, such as endurance athletes with type 1 diabetes
    Tools and original data Mostly static pages Validated calculators and trackers, reader surveys, analysis of public health datasets

    Market fit is a gap in its own right. Aleyda Solis’s analysis of the May 2026 core update found visibility shifts driven by intent, market fit and source type, including UK results moving from US.com retailers towards local-market domains. That analysis was not specific to health, so treat it as a pattern to check in your own results, not a finding about your niche. Health content is local by nature, though: rebates, regulators, approved medicines and referral rules differ by country, and a publisher writing for one health system can be more useful to those readers than a large foreign site writing for everyone.

    Hypothetical example:

    An Australian publisher covering coeliac disease has 400 articles. About half are definitional pages that sit on page two behind health department, hospital and patient-organisation pages. The other half cover eating out, reading labels, travel, gluten-free product comparisons and costs, and they earn most of the clicks. The rational move is not another rewrite of the definitional pages. It is consolidating them into a few well-referenced explainers that link to the institutional sources, and moving the budget into tested product comparisons, a maintained guide to Australian labelling rules, and an annual reader survey published as original data.

    Trust signals that are real, not decorative

    None of this works without the basics that Google’s guidance and readers both look for, including content that is, in the guidance’s words, “written or reviewed by an expert or enthusiast who demonstrably knows the topic well”. For an independent publisher that means:

    • Clinical reviewers who actually change the content, with a review date that reflects a real review. A reviewer’s name on a page nobody reviewed is a liability, not a signal.
    • Citations to primary research and clinical guidelines, and a visible corrections process.
    • Affiliate and advertising disclosures next to the content they affect, and a clear line between editorial and commercial pages.
    • No scaled, lightly edited AI condition pages. Google’s spam policies treat scaled content created mainly to manipulate rankings as abuse however it is produced, and on health topics the accuracy risk to readers is worse than the ranking risk.

    Channels that do not run through the head-term results

    For an independent health publisher, the durable asset is an audience that chooses you. Search can feed it, but it should not be the whole plan.

    • Email and community. A newsletter or member community built around a condition gives you return visits that survive ranking changes, and a direct line to the questions readers are actually asking.
    • Video. If the German finding holds more widely, clinician-led video may be a route into health AI Overview citations that does not require outranking a hospital. Treat that as a reason to test, not a certainty.
    • Preferred sources. Google has expanded preferred sources to AI Mode and AI Overviews, and in August 2026 gave publishers an embeddable button asking readers to add them; Google says users are about twice as likely to click a preferred source, according to TechCrunch. Loyal readers are the ones who will add you, so it rewards audience building rather than replacing it. Check availability in your market.
    • Partnerships. Patient organisations, clinics and professional bodies can cite and share independent resources that fill their gaps, especially practical guides and tools they do not produce themselves.

    How to tell whether it is working

    Sitewide organic traffic is the wrong scoreboard for this strategy, because definitional pages losing clicks to AI Overviews can hide growth elsewhere. Measure by query class instead.

    1. Tag queries into classes: definitional, practical, product, cost and access, research, and branded. Search Console’s branded queries filter helps with the last.
    2. Track clicks, top-three share and the number of pages earning impressions for each class, month on month.
    3. Use the Search generative AI performance report to see which pages earn impressions in AI features. It shows impressions only, not clicks, and it reached all eligible sites worldwide on 31 August 2026.
    4. Track the audience measures the business runs on: newsletter sign-ups per 1,000 sessions, returning readers and branded search demand.

    The signal to act on: if practical, product and cost pages grow while definitional pages hold flat or decline, the strategy is working even if total traffic is flat. If a class keeps losing to institutions after you have published your best work on it, stop investing there and move the budget.

    The realistic position

    If I ran an independent health site, I would stop measuring myself against hospitals on “what is” queries, consolidate the definitional pages into a small set of well-referenced explainers, and put the budget into the query classes institutions leave open, with reviewers who genuinely review and disclosures readers can see. Then I would judge the plan by clicks per query class and by audience growth, not by whether the site finally outranks a health department on a head term. That fight is expensive and uncertain. The gaps institutions leave are where an independent publisher can be the best result on the page.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.