Discussion starter: a digital PR question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Digital PR
Have you seen clear negative effects from paid links recently, or has Google mostly neutralised them so they are simply wasted money?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Paid links can still cause clear damage, but the damage you can attribute with confidence is narrower than penalty stories suggest, and “neutralised” does not mean harmless. From outside Google, a bought link has three possible fates: it passes value, it is ignored, or it contributes to a manual action or a demotion. Only the manual action is directly visible to you. That is why public evidence on this topic is mostly anecdote, and why “penalty or wasted money?” is the wrong frame for a budget decision.
The better question is what money is worth when its effect cannot be measured cleanly and it carries a small but real chance of an expensive clean-up. Judged that way, paying for followed links to move rankings is a poor bet, not because it reliably gets punished, but because neither the upside nor the risk can be sized in advance.
What Google’s policy says, at the strength it says it
Google’s spam policies list “Buying or selling links for ranking purposes” as link spam. That covers money for links or for posts that contain links, goods or services for links, and products sent in exchange for a write-up that includes a link. The same policy accepts that buying and selling links “is a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes”, and says such links are not a violation as long as they carry
rel="nofollow"orrel="sponsored".On consequences, Google says it detects violations “both through automated systems and, as needed, human review that can result in a manual action”, and that sites violating its policies “may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all”. The operative word is “may”. The policy describes what can happen to a violating site. It does not say what happens to each bought link, and Google does not publish how often each outcome occurs.
Why “neutralised” and “penalised” can look the same in your data
A useful comparison:
A bank that spots a counterfeit note takes it out of circulation. It does not necessarily close your account. Deposit enough fakes in a clear pattern, though, and someone opens a file on you. Either way, the money you paid for the fakes is gone. In search terms, “out of circulation” means Google’s systems decline to count the link, and “opening a file” means human review that can end in a manual action.
What happens to the link What you see Visible in Search Console? What it costs Counted Possible ranking gains, mixed in with every other cause No The fee, plus exposure if it is discounted later Ignored from the start Nothing No The fee and the opportunity cost Counted, then discounted Pages that relied on it fall, possibly around a spam update No, only by inference Rankings you had come to rely on Part of a manual action A notice in the Manual actions report and traffic loss on affected pages or the whole site Yes Clean-up time, a review request, and lost revenue while it lasts The third row is a plausible explanation for some “we got penalised” stories. When links that were counted stop being counted, rankings built on them fall. The site was not demoted as a punishment; it lost value it had borrowed. An automated demotion, which the policy’s “may rank lower” also allows for, would look much the same from outside. That is why a drop after a spam update is weak evidence either way.
There is also a structural reason to expect Google to prefer ignoring links over punishing the sites they point at. If bought links reliably sank their targets, anyone could damage a competitor by buying links to it. Discounting the links removes that incentive. That is reasoning, not a documented mechanism, but it fits the policy’s hedged wording.
Where the risk concentrates
Risk is not spread evenly across buyers. Based on how the policy is written and how pattern detection works in general, these situations raise it:
- Rankings that rest mainly on paid links. If the links are discounted, nothing else holds the pages up, so the drop is largest.
- Placements on sites that sell to anyone. A site whose outbound links are for sale is easier to classify than a single sponsored mention, and once it is classified, its links are likely to lose value as a group.
- Keyword-rich anchors repeated at scale. Each placement can look editorial while the aggregate pattern does not.
- Paid posts in publisher sections that exist to rank third-party content. When a section serves that purpose rather than the publisher’s readers, it can fall under Google’s site reputation abuse policy. Since August 2026, the manual action impact of that policy no longer applies in the EEA; instead, the affected section may be separated in Google’s systems so it ranks independently. Outside the EEA, manual actions still apply. Google has not documented what either outcome means for links from such sections, but I would not expect a separated or demoted section to pass the host site’s authority.
- Selling links yourself. The policy covers sellers as well as buyers, so a publisher selling followed links puts the trust in its own outbound links at risk.
Separately from Google, paid editorial that is not disclosed as advertising can breach advertising and consumer-protection rules in many markets. That brand and legal exposure does not show up in an SEO report.
What the public evidence can and cannot tell you
The documentation, meaning the policy and the Manual actions report, establishes that negative outcomes exist. It says nothing about how often they occur. Controlled public experiments are hard to run for an obvious reason: a proper test means breaking the policy on a site someone cares about. No controlled public test exists that I can point to measuring how often bought links are counted, ignored or punished.
Practitioner reports run in both directions and carry a selection bias. Sellers publicise wins; site owners who received manual actions have little reason to publish the details. The persistence of a paid-link market shows that buyers believe some links work. It is not evidence that they do, or that they keep working.
So if someone says paid links are simply ignored now, they are describing one of three outcomes as if it were the only one. If someone says any paid link will get you penalised, the documentation does not support that certainty either.
How to check whether past paid links hurt you
- Check the Manual actions report first. An unnatural links action there is the only unambiguous signal. If you have one, follow the remediation steps in the notice and request a review once the links are dealt with.
- List the paid placements from invoices and outreach records, not only from a backlink tool. Tools miss links and cannot tell you which ones were paid for.
- Compare target pages with similar pages that received no paid links. Look at query-level clicks and positions around Google’s announced spam updates and core updates, using the dates on the Google Search Status Dashboard.
- Check whether losses concentrate on the queries that match paid anchor text. A drop limited to those queries fits discounted links better than a broad quality reassessment.
- Look at referral traffic from each placement. A placement that never sent a visit has only the link to justify its cost, so its value rests entirely on Google counting it.
Then read the pattern at the right strength. Target pages falling while comparison pages hold, around a spam update, is consistent with discounted links, not proof of it. Both groups falling around a core update points away from links as the main cause. Nothing moving at all means either the links never counted or they still do, and you cannot tell which.
Deciding what to do with the budget
What you are paying for How to judge it Policy position Audience: a placement that readers in your market actually see Referral visits, assisted conversions, branded search in that market Compliant with rel="sponsored"Association: sponsorships, events, community programs Branded search, direct traffic, sales-team feedback, links earned as a side effect Compliant when paid links are qualified Rankings: followed links bought to move positions Cannot be isolated from other ranking causes Link spam under Google’s policy Money spent on audience is not wasted even if the link passes nothing, because you judge it on visits and brand demand you can measure. Money spent purely on followed links has no measurable return by design, which is the real problem with it.
Hypothetical example:
A home services business bought 60 guest posts over two years, each with a followed, keyword-rich anchor to one of eight service pages. There is no manual action. Three of the eight pages lost positions around a spam update; the other five, and a set of similar pages with no paid links, held steady. That pattern is consistent with some links being discounted, but a competitor’s gains could produce the same picture. What the business can say with confidence is narrower: it cannot show a return on the spend, and the pages most exposed are the ones whose rankings rest on those placements. The sensible move is to stop buying, redirect the budget to placements judged on referral traffic and branded search, and strengthen the three pages on their own merits.
What would change this view
A transparent dataset showing sites with otherwise natural link profiles being demoted after buying a modest number of links would shift the balance towards “harmful”. So would a change in Google’s policy wording, or a documented wave of link-related manual actions. In the other direction, evidence that followed paid links reliably keep their value through spam updates would make “wasted money” the wrong description. No such public evidence exists that I can point to in either direction, so my position sits in the middle: treat links bought for rankings as spend with an unmeasurable return and a real, if modest, tail risk, and move that budget to placements whose value you can measure.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.