Discussion starter: an SEO measurement question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- SEO Analytics
Has share of search (your brand’s share of category brand searches) predicted revenue better than rankings for you?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Share of search and rankings answer different questions, so it is not surprising that share of search often tracks revenue better. Share of search, your brand’s share of all branded searches in a category, measures demand for the brand, which is closely tied to market share. Rankings measure visibility for queries, which is one input to how much of that demand, and of non-brand demand, you capture. Les Binet’s work for the IPA in 2020 popularised share of search precisely because it tended to move with market share and sometimes ahead of it. For a revenue forecast, share of search is usually the better leading indicator; for diagnosing and improving SEO performance, rankings and non-brand clicks remain the tools.
Why share of search tracks revenue
People search for brands they are considering. When more of the category’s branded searches are for your brand, more buyers have you in mind, and that tends to show up in sales. Advertising, PR, word of mouth, product quality and distribution all feed into it. Rankings, by contrast, can improve without anyone new wanting your product, and can fall without demand changing, for example when AI features or new competitors change the results page.
How to calculate it
- Define the category’s brands: your brand and the main competitors buyers consider.
- Collect branded search volume for each, using Google Trends (relative, and comparable across brands in one query), keyword tools or, for your own brand, Search Console. The branded queries filter in Search Console helps separate your own brand demand.
- Compute your share of the total each month, and smooth it over a rolling period to reduce noise.
- Handle ambiguous brand names by adding a category term or excluding unrelated meanings.
How to test whether it predicts your revenue
- Collect at least two or three years of monthly share of search and revenue.
- Check correlations at different lags: does share of search move with revenue, or lead it by a few months?
- Compare with a rankings-based measure, such as a visibility index on your priority keywords, over the same period.
- Hold out the most recent year and see which measure would have predicted it better.
- Account for seasonality and major events, such as price changes, product launches or distribution changes.
Measure What it reflects Best use Share of search Brand demand relative to competitors Leading indicator for revenue and market share; brand health Rankings and visibility How well pages are positioned for queries Diagnosing SEO performance; prioritising work Non-brand organic clicks Traffic captured from people not yet looking for you Measuring SEO’s contribution to acquisition Branded organic clicks Capture of brand demand Checking that brand demand reaches your site Caveats worth stating
- It is not an SEO metric. SEO influences it only indirectly, through discovery that later becomes brand demand. Reporting it as SEO performance credits SEO for advertising and product work.
- Search behaviour is shifting. Buyers who ask assistants for recommendations may search brand names less or differently, which could change how share of search behaves over time. Watch whether its relationship with revenue weakens.
- Data quality varies. Google Trends values are sampled and relative; keyword tool volumes are estimates; small brands may have too little data.
- Category boundaries matter. Adding or dropping a competitor changes the share.
Hypothetical example:
A mattress brand compares three years of monthly share of search, calculated from Google Trends against five competitors, with its revenue and with a visibility index for its priority keywords. Share of search moves with revenue and tends to change a couple of months before it; visibility does not show a consistent relationship, rising during a period when revenue fell because a competitor’s advertising campaign shifted demand. The brand adds share of search to its board reporting as a leading indicator, and keeps visibility and non-brand clicks in the SEO team’s reporting.
Getting usable data from Google Trends
Google Trends is the most common source for share of search, and it has quirks worth knowing. Values are relative within each query, scaled to the highest point, so compare brands in the same query rather than stitching separate queries together. Results are based on samples, so pulling the same query on different days can give slightly different numbers; average several pulls or use longer time ranges. Small brands may show zeros in some periods simply because they fall below the reporting threshold. Topic entities can capture spelling variants and translations, but they also sometimes include unrelated meanings, so check what a topic includes before relying on it. Keep a record of exactly which terms, topics, countries and date ranges you used, so the series can be reproduced and extended consistently every month.
Using both together
The most useful reports put share of search next to SEO metrics and explain the relationship. If share of search is rising and branded organic clicks are not, the site may not be capturing growing brand demand: check brand result pages for competitors’ ads, review sites and marketplace listings. If share of search is flat and non-brand clicks are growing, SEO is bringing in new people who may become brand searchers later. Each metric explains something the other cannot.
Share of search is the better predictor of revenue for most brands, because it measures demand; rankings are the better tool for managing SEO, because they measure what SEO controls. Use share of search to forecast and to frame SEO’s contribution, and do not report it as an SEO result.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.