Discussion starter: a digital PR question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Digital PR
Competitor link gap analysis: still a useful starting point, or does copying competitors’ links just produce the same mediocre profile?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Competitor link gap analysis is a useful discovery tool and a poor strategy. As a starting point it shows you where your market’s links come from: associations, industry publications, partners, suppliers, events, resource pages and the kinds of content that attract coverage. As a to-do list it produces exactly the outcome you describe, a profile that looks like everyone else’s, heavy on links anyone can get and light on the links that set a site apart. The fix is to read the gap for patterns and reasons rather than for URLs, and then build around the things you have that competitors do not.
What a gap list is actually telling you
Every link in a competitor’s profile exists for a reason. Sorting the gap by reason turns a list of domains into insight.
Why the link exists Example What to do with it Membership or relationship Industry association directory, supplier’s partner page, chamber of commerce Replicate where you have an equivalent real relationship An asset that earned it Links to a competitor’s salary survey, calculator or annual report Learn the asset type that attracts links in your niche; build a better or different one Editorial coverage Trade press quoting the competitor’s CEO Identify the journalists and angles; develop your own expert voice Events and sponsorships Conference speaker pages, sponsored community events Consider only if the event has value for your business beyond the link Low-quality or paid Guest posts on unrelated blogs, link farms, directories with no editorial standard Ignore; copying these adds risk and nothing else Look at pages, not domains
The most useful view of a competitor’s links is by target page. Which pages on their site attract the most referring domains? In most niches you find a small number of assets doing most of the work: a piece of research, a tool, a definitive guide, a data page. That tells you what the market links to. Copying their linking domains is copying the outcome; understanding their linked pages is understanding the cause.
Why copying produces a mediocre profile
- The easy links are easy for everyone. Directories and resource pages that list every competitor add little distinction.
- The hard links are tied to things you do not have. A competitor’s link from a university exists because of a research partnership. Emailing the university will not reproduce it.
- Some of the gap is junk. Many competitor profiles include paid or manipulative links. Copying them imports their risk.
- You end up following. By the time you earn the links a competitor has, they have moved on to the next ones.
A better way to use the analysis
- Run the gap against several competitors, not one, and look for domains linking to most of them. Those are the sites that define relevance in your niche. Some are worth pursuing directly, especially associations, standards bodies and major trade publications.
- Classify the rest by reason using the table above.
- List your own unique assets: proprietary data, specialist staff, customer base, partnerships, local presence, product capabilities. These are the link sources competitors cannot copy from you.
- Match assets to the link types that work in your niche. If research earns links and you have data nobody else has, a study is the obvious move.
- Prioritise links that also bring customers: referral traffic from a relevant trade publication or partner page is worth more than a link from a high-authority site nobody in your market reads.
Hypothetical example:
A recruitment firm runs a gap analysis against three competitors and finds 400 domains linking to them but not to it. By domain, the list looks like a long outreach campaign. By reason, it looks different: about 60 are industry associations and job boards the firm is eligible for, about 150 link to one competitor’s annual salary guide, and most of the rest are low-quality directories and old guest posts. The firm joins the relevant associations, ignores the directories and, because it places thousands of candidates a year, publishes its own salary data with a different angle: pay by region and company size. That study earns links the competitors do not have, which is the point.
Running the analysis without drowning in it
Raw gap exports are long and mostly noise. A few filters make them workable. Remove sitewide links such as footer and blogroll links, which inflate counts without telling you much. Remove domains that link to every site in the niche indiscriminately, such as scraper and aggregator sites. Keep only referring domains that link to at least two of the competitors you compared, which surfaces the sites that matter to the sector as a whole. Then look at the top of what remains by relevance and real traffic, not only by a tool’s authority score, because a small trade association with an engaged membership can matter more than a high-scoring general site. Time-box the exercise to a day. If it takes a week, you are building a list to work through rather than learning what the market links to.
Signs your profile is becoming a copy
- Most new links come from sites that also link to every competitor.
- Few links point to anything other than the homepage.
- Links arrive through outreach campaigns rather than because someone found something worth citing.
- Referral traffic from new links is close to zero.
Where gap analysis still earns its place
It is quick, cheap and good at catching obvious omissions: the association you forgot to join, the supplier who lists partners but not you, the trade directory everyone in the sector uses. It is also useful for spotting when a competitor’s link acquisition suddenly accelerates, which often signals a new asset or campaign worth understanding. Keep it as a quarterly check and a source of ideas. Build the strategy on what makes you worth linking to.
Run the gap, take the relationship links you genuinely qualify for, study the assets behind the best links, ignore the junk, and put most of the effort into links that only your business could earn.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.