Discussion starter: a programmatic SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Technical SEO
Aleyda Solis’s May 2026 analysis found transactional marketplaces gaining while reference aggregators fell. Does that match your marketplace data?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Aleyda Solis’s analysis of the May 2026 core update found that the biggest visibility shifts were driven by intent, market fit and source type, with transactional marketplaces gaining, reference aggregators falling, forums and Q&A sites losing UK visibility, and UK results moving from US.com retailers towards local-market domains. I cannot share another company’s data, but the useful question for any marketplace is whether its own pages follow the same pattern, and that can be checked directly by segmenting performance by page type around the update dates. Most marketplaces contain both kinds of page, transactional listing and category pages and reference-style pages such as guides, price aggregations and informational hubs, and the update may have treated them differently.
How to check your own data
- Classify pages by type: transactional (listings, categories, search results pages you index, product pages), reference (guides, glossaries, price and statistics pages, aggregated information), community (Q&A, reviews), and brand or support pages.
- Compare clicks and impressions for each type in equal periods before and after the update, allowing for seasonality with a year-on-year comparison where possible.
- Segment by market if you operate in several countries, to see whether market fit affected you, for example in the UK.
- Look at query intent groups: transactional queries versus informational ones, independent of page type.
- Check which sites gained on your lost queries, and what type of source they are.
What the patterns would mean
What you see Likely reading Response Transactional pages up, reference pages down Matches the analysis: task-completion pages favoured over summaries Invest in transactional pages; review whether reference pages add anything beyond what they aggregate Both down Something broader: quality, market fit or competition Look at which sources gained and why Losses concentrated in one market Market fit, such as local competitors with local pricing and delivery Strengthen local signals: currency, delivery, returns, local inventory No clear change The update did not target your page types significantly Continue as planned; monitor next updates Why reference aggregators are vulnerable
Pages that summarise information available elsewhere, such as average prices compiled from public sources, lists of options drawn from other sites, or definitions, are exactly the kind of content that AI answers and more direct sources now provide. Aleyda’s summary of the update put it strongly: derivative layers need a much stronger reason to exist in the results. For a marketplace, reference pages built on its own transaction data, such as real prices paid, real availability and real demand, are a different matter; they contain information only the marketplace has.
Hypothetical example:
A used equipment marketplace segments its pages after the May 2026 update. Category and listing pages gained modestly; its “price guides”, which summarised prices from manufacturers’ and other sites’ data, lost a large share of clicks, mostly to manufacturers and AI answers. Its “sold price” pages, built from its own completed transactions, held steady. The marketplace rebuilds its price guides around its own sold data, drops the summary content, and links each guide to live listings. The rebuilt guides recover part of their visibility over the next months, and conversions from them rise because they now lead directly to inventory.
Watch for this:
An industry analysis describes patterns across many sites. Your site may not follow them, and acting on the general pattern without checking your own segments can lead to cutting pages that were not affected. Segment first, then decide.
Transactional strength is not only about page type
If transactional marketplaces gained, it is worth asking why: plausibly because they let users complete a task, with current inventory, prices, availability and a way to act. A marketplace’s category and listing pages benefit most when they deliver on that: fresh inventory, accurate prices, clear filters, trustworthy seller information and a smooth path to purchase. Thin category pages with few listings, stale inventory or poor filters may not share in the gains. Review your transactional pages against that standard rather than assuming their page type alone protects them.
Market fit is worth checking separately
The analysis also found UK results moving towards local-market domains, with market fit rather than the domain itself as the lever. Marketplaces operating across countries should check whether their pages in each market show local currency, local delivery and returns, local inventory and local support. Where a marketplace serves a market from another country’s inventory or with foreign pricing, local competitors may now have an advantage in results.
Segment your data by page type, market and intent around the update, compare with the analysis rather than assuming it applies, strengthen transactional pages and rebuild reference content around your own data, and check market fit in each country you serve.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.