Discussion starter: a YMYL SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- AI Search
- Content SEO
AI Overviews give medical answers citing competitors. What, if anything, has changed citation patterns in your YMYL niche?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
For medical queries, Google’s AI Overviews tend to cite a small set of sources that already carry strong reputations for health information: national health services, major clinics and hospitals, and established medical publishers. Changing that pattern is slow and uncertain, and nobody has published a controlled test that shows what shifts it. What seems to give a site a better chance of being cited is being the best available source for a specific sub-question, with clear clinical authorship and review, current dates, answers consistent with medical consensus, and a reputation that other health organisations recognise. Trying to out-compete the national health service for “what is diabetes” is unlikely to work; being the clearest source for a specific procedure, population or service can.
Why health AI answers look the way they do
Google’s guidance says its systems give more weight to expertise and trustworthiness for topics that can affect health, and its quality rater guidelines ask for health content to be accurate and consistent with established medical consensus. AI features on health queries reflect that caution. Sources with long records of accurate, reviewed content, strong external recognition and clear authorship are the safest choices for a system summarising health information. For some health queries, Google may not show an AI Overview at all.
Where a smaller site can realistically be cited
Query type Typical cited sources Opportunity for a specialist site General condition definitions National health services, major clinics Low Specific procedures and recovery Major hospitals, specialist clinics Moderate, if content is detailed and clinically led Specific populations (children, older adults, athletes) Mixed Moderate to high for specialists Practical service questions (cost, process, what to expect at an appointment) Providers and patient organisations High Local availability Business Profiles, local providers High for local providers What plausibly improves the odds
- Answer specific sub-questions precisely. Recovery timelines, preparation steps, risks by patient group and practical details that general sources summarise briefly.
- Clinical authorship and review, shown clearly. Named clinicians with registration details and review dates.
- Consistency with consensus. Content that departs from mainstream guidance without strong evidence is unlikely to be cited and may be judged harshly.
- Current information. Update content when guidelines change, and show when it was last reviewed.
- Clear structure. Headings that state the point and first sentences that answer the question make passages easier to use.
- External recognition. Links and mentions from health organisations, professional bodies and reputable media, which take time to build.
Measure before and after
- Track a set of health prompts relevant to your specialty, run repeatedly, recording which sources are cited.
- Use Search Console’s “Search generative AI performance” report to see which of your pages receive AI impressions.
- Compare your cited and uncited pages with the pages that are cited: depth, authorship, date, clarity.
- Expect changes to appear slowly and irregularly; judge over quarters rather than weeks.
Hypothetical example:
A specialist knee surgery clinic finds AI Overviews for knee replacement questions cite a national health service and two large hospitals. It stops trying to compete on “what is a knee replacement” and rewrites its pages on specific questions: recovery milestones week by week, returning to driving, kneeling after surgery and differences for younger patients, each written and reviewed by its surgeons with review dates. Over several months, prompt tracking shows its pages cited for some of those specific questions, while general questions still cite the large institutions. Appointment enquiries from organic search rise, mainly from the recovery pages.
Partnerships widen the evidence base
For specialist providers, one route into the sources that AI features trust is working with the organisations those systems already cite. Contributing clinical expertise to patient organisations’ information, co-authoring resources with professional bodies, taking part in guideline development or research, and speaking at professional events all create references to your clinicians and your site from sources with established reputations. These are slow, but they are also the kind of recognition Google’s quality guidance describes, and they benefit patients directly. A clinic whose surgeons are cited by the relevant patient charity has a reputational signal no amount of on-page work can replace.
When competitors are cited and you are not
Before assuming the system is biased, compare honestly. Look at the cited competitor pages for the questions you care about: are they more specific, more current, better structured or more clearly reviewed? In many cases the competitor’s page is simply the better answer, and the fix is on your side. Where your content is genuinely stronger, the gap is more likely to be reputation, which grows through recognition from the wider health community rather than through page changes alone.
Watch for this:
Changing medical content to match phrasing seen in AI answers, or adding claims to appear more comprehensive, risks accuracy. Every change to health content should go through clinical review, whatever the search motivation.
Compete for specific, practical questions where your clinical expertise is strongest, show clinical authorship and review clearly, keep content current and consistent with consensus, build recognition from the health community, and measure citations patiently. General health queries will remain dominated by the largest institutions for the foreseeable future.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.