Discussion
  • AI Search

AI assistants keep inventing URLs on your domain that 404. Do you redirect the invented URLs to real pages, or leave them alone?

Published 1 reply

Discussion starter: an AI search question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.

Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.

1 reply

  • admin
    Admin
    Original poster

    Handle them for users, not for search. When assistants invent URLs on your domain, people who click them land on 404 pages, which is a poor experience and a lost visitor. Redirecting an invented URL makes sense when it clearly corresponds to a real page, such as an assistant linking to /pricing/enterprise when your enterprise pricing lives at /plans/enterprise. Leave the rest as 404s, but make the 404 page genuinely helpful. And look at what the invented URLs are asking for: repeated inventions of the same kind of URL often reveal a question people are asking that your site does not answer clearly, which is a content gap worth filling.

    How to find invented URLs

    • Filter analytics for 404 page views with AI assistant referrers or AI-related UTM parameters.
    • Check server logs for 404s requested by user-triggered AI fetchers, which fetch pages when users ask an assistant about them.
    • Review Search Console’s “Not found (404)” examples for URL patterns that never existed on the site.
    • Group the invented URLs by what they seem to want: pricing, features, documentation, comparisons.

    Deciding what to do with each

    Invented URL Response
    Clearly matches a real page under a different path 301 to the real page
    Asks for something you have but spread across pages Consider creating a page that answers it directly
    Asks for something you do not offer Leave as 404; make sure your pages say clearly what you do offer
    Random or one-off Leave as 404

    What not to do

    Redirecting every 404 to the homepage or a generic page is tempting and counterproductive. Users who wanted something specific end up somewhere irrelevant, and Google may treat mass redirects to unrelated pages as soft 404s. Keep redirects for genuine matches only, and let other invented URLs return an honest 404.

    Make the 404 page useful

    • A clear message that the page does not exist.
    • A search box.
    • Links to the most commonly sought sections: pricing, product features, documentation, support, contact.
    • Where you can infer intent from the URL, a suggested page, without automatically redirecting.
    • A correct 404 status code, so search engines do not index it.

    Reduce inventions at the source

    Assistants tend to invent URLs when they know a site has information on a topic but cannot find the specific page. Clear, stable URLs for important information, such as pricing, key features, integrations and policies, pages that state those facts plainly, and good internal linking make it more likely that assistants retrieve and cite real pages. Avoid changing URLs of important pages, since assistants and their sources may carry old URLs for a long time.

    Hypothetical example:

    A software company notices a steady flow of 404s from ChatGPT referrals to URLs like /features/sso, /integrations/salesforce and /pricing/enterprise. Its real pages are /security, /apps/salesforce and /plans. It redirects the matching patterns to the real pages, and notices that many invented URLs ask about specific integrations that exist but have no dedicated pages. It builds integration pages at logical URLs, and the number of invented-URL 404s falls. Assistant referrals begin landing on real pages, and conversion from AI referrals improves.

    Watch for this:

    Creating pages at invented URLs purely because an assistant guessed them can produce a scattered structure that does not match your site. Create pages where the need is real, and place them where they fit your information architecture; redirects from invented patterns can then point to them.

    Invented URLs as a signal about your site’s clarity

    Assistants tend to guess URLs when they cannot find a page that clearly answers the question. A high rate of invented URLs for a topic often means the relevant information is buried in a long page, split across several, or phrased in a way that does not match how people ask. Checking whether each common invented pattern corresponds to a clear, well-linked page on your site is a quick audit of how findable your key information is, for assistants and for people alike.

    Keep monitoring

    Invented URLs change as models and their sources change. Review AI-referred 404s monthly, add redirects for new clear matches, and look for new patterns that suggest content gaps. It is a small task that turns a frustrating experience into a source of insight about what people ask assistants about your business.

    Redirect invented URLs that clearly match real pages, leave the rest as 404s with a genuinely helpful 404 page, fill real content gaps the patterns reveal, keep important URLs stable and clear, and never mass-redirect 404s to the homepage.

    Need help with this on your own site?

    Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.

    See SEO services

Add a reply

Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.