Discussion starter: a content SEO question, posted with an answer from Niraj Raut to open the thread. If you have dealt with this on a site, reply with what you saw, especially where it differs.
- Content SEO
- Internal Linking
A blog post outranks the category page for a commercial query. Merge them, de-optimise the post, or push more internal links to the category?
Disclosure: Niraj Raut, who posted this answer, runs the SEO consultancy linked at the end of it.
1 reply
-
adminAdmin
Before choosing among the three, check what the results page is telling you. If the results for the query are mostly guides and articles, Google is reading the intent as informational or mixed, and your category page may not be the right answer however many links you give it; in that case, make the post convert better rather than fighting it. If the results are mostly category and product pages from other retailers, Google wants a category page and yours is losing on strength; strengthen it with internal links and better content, and adjust the post so it stops targeting the commercial term directly. Merging is rarely right for a blog post and a category page, because they serve different needs.
Step one: read the results
- Mostly category pages from competitors: the query is transactional. Your category page should win; the post outranking it points to a weakness in the category page or to the post over-targeting the term.
- Mostly guides and reviews: the query is informational or evaluative. The post may be the right page, and the job is converting its traffic.
- A mix: both pages might rank, which can be the best outcome if they appear together.
Also check whether the two pages swap positions over time for the query. Search Console’s performance report, filtered by the query and grouped by page, shows whether Google alternates between them. Frequent swapping is a sign of cannibalisation; a stable preference for the post is a sign Google thinks it is a better match.
What each option does
Option When it fits Risk Push more internal links to the category Results favour category pages and yours is under-linked Low; can be done first and measured De-optimise the post The post’s title and heading target the commercial term directly If Google preferred the post because the category page is weak, you may lose both Merge the post into the category The post is thin and adds little beyond what the category page should say You lose the informational page and its other rankings Leave the post ranking and improve its path to products Results favour guides Low; accepts the intent Google sees A sequence that limits the downside
- Strengthen the category page first. Add a short, useful introduction that helps shoppers choose, check the title and heading match the commercial query, and make sure the category is linked from navigation and relevant pages with descriptive anchors.
- Add a prominent, contextual link from the post to the category, using the category’s name as anchor text. That tells both readers and search engines which page is the commercial destination.
- Adjust the post’s targeting if it uses the commercial term as its main title. Reframe it around the informational angle it actually serves (“How to choose…”, “What to look for in…”), keeping the content intact.
- Wait and measure after each change. Give Google time to recrawl both pages before the next change, so you know which one worked.
- Consider merging only if the post is thin and duplicates what the category page should say. If it has its own links, traffic from other queries or distinct value, keep it.
Watch for this:
De-optimising the post first is the common mistake. If Google ranked the post because your category page is weak, removing the post’s relevance leaves nothing strong in its place, and a competitor takes the position. Strengthen the page you want to rank before weakening the one that ranks now.
Why the post often wins
It helps to understand why a blog post beats a category page in the first place. Common reasons include: the post has external links and the category page has none; the post has substantial text and the category page is a grid with a heading; the post’s title matches the query wording better; the category page is deep in the navigation; or the category page is filtered, paginated or canonicalised in ways that weaken it. Each of these points to a specific fix on the category page.
Hypothetical example:
A kitchenware retailer’s post “The best cast iron pans for home cooks” outranks its “Cast iron pans” category for “cast iron pans”. The results show mostly retailer category pages, so the intent is transactional. The team adds a short buying note and filters for size and brand to the category page, links to it from the kitchenware navigation and from four related guides, and changes the post’s title to “How to choose a cast iron pan” with a prominent link to the category. After recrawling, the category page moves above the post for the head term, while the post keeps ranking for “how to choose” and “best cast iron pan for beginners”. Both pages now earn traffic, for different queries.
When two results are better than one
For mixed-intent queries, having both a category page and a guide on page one can be the best outcome: you occupy two positions and serve both kinds of searcher. If your data shows the two pages ranking together without swapping, and both getting clicks, leave them alone. Cannibalisation is only a problem when the pages compete for the same slot and weaken each other.
Read the results, strengthen the category page and its links first, redirect the post’s targeting towards its informational angle, and only merge when the post has nothing of its own to offer. Measure after each step, not after all of them.
Need help with this on your own site?
Niraj Raut works with businesses in Nepal, Australia, the UK, Europe and the US on technical SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO and AI search.
Add a reply Cancel reply
Replies are open to approved members. Log in or apply to join.